keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Custom AI Chips: Questions to Ask Cloud Providers

Card No. 06·71856 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Before you commit to a cloud provider’s custom AI chip, you need to ask pointed questions about performance, software maturity, pricing, and lock-in. This article outlines the key questions to ask, explains why they matter, and gives you the background to evaluate the answers.

Why Custom AI Chips Are Different

Custom AI chips—like Google’s TPU, Amazon’s Trainium/Inferentia, and Microsoft’s Maia—are designed to accelerate machine learning workloads more efficiently than general-purpose GPUs. They often deliver better price-performance for specific models, but they come with trade-offs. Unlike GPUs, which have a mature ecosystem of libraries and frameworks, custom chips may require you to adapt your code, use proprietary SDKs, or rely on the provider’s specific tooling. That means the decision isn’t just about hardware specs; it’s about how the chip fits into your existing workflow and whether you can leave if needed.

What to Ask About Performance and Benchmarks

Performance claims can be misleading. Providers often quote peak teraflops or TOPS, but real-world throughput depends on your model, batch size, and data types. Ask for:

  • Benchmarks on your specific workload: Run a representative model (or a close proxy) on their chip and compare latency and throughput against your current GPU baseline.
  • Performance with mixed precision: Many AI workloads use FP16, BF16, or INT8. Ask for numbers in the precision you actually use, not just FP32.
  • Scaling behavior: How does performance change as you add more chips? Is the scaling linear, or does communication overhead dominate?
  • Memory bandwidth and capacity: For large models, memory can be the bottleneck. Ask about HBM capacity and bandwidth, and how that affects batch sizes you can run.

Software and Framework Compatibility

The biggest risk with custom chips is software lock-in. Most AI teams use PyTorch or TensorFlow, and they rely on CUDA (for NVIDIA) or ROCm (for AMD) to run efficiently. Custom chips often require a different stack. Ask:

  • Which frameworks are natively supported? Is it just PyTorch, or also TensorFlow, JAX, and ONNX?
  • What is the level of operator coverage? Some chips support only a subset of operations. If your model uses an unsupported op, you may need to rewrite it or use a fallback to CPU/GPU.
  • What is the maturity of the compiler? A compiler that is still evolving may produce slower code or fail on complex graphs. Ask about known issues and the roadmap.
  • Is there a compatibility layer? Some providers offer an XLA or a CUDA-like abstraction. Test it with your code before committing.

Pricing and Total Cost of Ownership

Custom chips are often marketed as cheaper per hour, but the total cost includes engineering time, migration effort, and potential inefficiencies. Ask:

  • What is the on-demand price per chip-hour? Compare with the GPU instances you currently use.
  • Are there reserved or committed-use discounts? These can lower costs but may lock you in for 1-3 years.
  • What is the cost of data transfer? Moving training data in and out of the provider’s network can add up. Ask about egress fees.
  • What is the cost of idle time? Some chips are billed per second, others per hour. If you have bursty workloads, that matters.
  • What is the cost of failure? If the chip fails or the instance is interrupted, do you get a refund? What is the SLA?

Portability and Lock-In Risks

If you build your model on a custom chip, can you move it elsewhere? This is a critical question that many teams overlook. Ask:

  • Is the SDK or runtime open-source? If the provider goes out of business or changes pricing, can you still run your code?
  • Can you export your model to a standard format (ONNX, SavedModel)? Even if you can, the performance may degrade on other hardware.
  • What is the provider’s track record on API stability? Have they deprecated features or changed the SDK in breaking ways?
  • Are there alternative providers offering the same chip? For example, Google’s TPU is only on Google Cloud, but some other chips are available via multiple clouds. If only one provider offers it, you are tied to that provider.

Reliability, Support, and Roadmap

Custom chips are often newer and less battle-tested than GPUs. You need to know what happens when something goes wrong. Ask:

  • What is the observed failure rate? Providers may not publish this, but you can ask for the SLA and any historical uptime data.
  • What is the support response time? If your training job fails at 2 AM, can you get help quickly? Is support included in the price?
  • What is the roadmap for the chip? Will there be a next generation? Will your code be compatible with it, or will you need to migrate again?
  • Are there any known hardware quirks? For example, some chips have limited memory, or they throttle under sustained load. Ask about thermal throttling and performance consistency.

Security and Compliance

Your data and models are sensitive. Custom chips are still just hardware, but the software stack may introduce new risks. Ask:

  • Is the chip certified for your compliance needs? If you handle healthcare or financial data, you may need certifications like HIPAA or SOC 2. Ask if the chip instances are covered.
  • How is data encrypted at rest and in transit? Custom chips may have different encryption capabilities than GPUs.
  • Can you run a fully isolated environment? Some custom chips are offered as bare-metal or with dedicated hosts. Ask about multi-tenancy and side-channel risks.
  • How are model weights protected? If you are using a proprietary model, you don’t want it exposed to other tenants. Ask about memory isolation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I run my existing PyTorch code on a custom AI chip without changes?

It depends on the chip and the framework support. For example, Google’s TPU works with PyTorch through the PyTorch/XLA library, but you may need to adjust your code for XLA semantics, like avoiding dynamic shapes. Amazon’s Trainium also has PyTorch support, but you may need to use their custom Neuron SDK. In many cases, simple models run with minimal changes, but complex models with custom ops may require significant refactoring.

How do custom chips compare to NVIDIA GPUs in terms of price-performance?

For inference, custom chips often win on price-performance, especially at scale. For training, the gap is narrower. You should benchmark your specific workload, because the results vary widely. Some users report 30-50% cost savings, while others see no benefit if their model doesn’t fit the chip’s architecture.

What happens if I want to switch to a different cloud provider later?

You can usually export your model to a standard format like ONNX, but you may lose performance optimizations. Your training pipeline may also be tied to the provider’s SDK. To minimize lock-in, keep your code as framework-agnostic as possible, and avoid using provider-specific APIs in your data pipeline.

Are custom AI chips suitable for small teams or startups?

They can be, if you are willing to invest time in migration. Some providers offer free credits for experimentation. However, if your team has limited ML engineering resources, the learning curve may not be worth it. Start with a small pilot project to assess the effort.

Do custom chips support multi-node training?

Yes, most do, but the interconnect and scaling efficiency vary. Ask about the network topology and whether the provider supports distributed training frameworks like Horovod or PyTorch DDP. Test with a multi-node job to see if the scaling is linear.

What is the typical lead time to get access to custom AI chips?

It varies. Some providers offer them on-demand, but others require you to request quota or sign up for a preview. If you need capacity for a specific deadline, ask about availability and whether there are regional restrictions.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →