If you are asking which cyberpunk trading and merchant games feel most like they were “stolen” — meaning cloned, heavily inspired, or directly lifted from another title — the honest answer is that no mainstream cyberpunk trading game is an outright theft. However, several titles share near-identical mechanics, UI layouts, and even narrative beats with earlier games, and a few have been the subject of plagiarism accusations. This article breaks down the most notable cases, the differences between inspiration and cloning, and how to spot a derivative game before you buy.
What “Stolen” Means in Game Design
In the context of cyberpunk trading games, “stolen” usually means one of three things: a direct code or asset theft (rare and legally actionable), a near-identical clone of a successful game’s mechanics (common in mobile and indie spaces), or a game that borrows so heavily from a single source that it feels like a reskin. The first is piracy, the second is imitation, and the third is a gray area that fans often call “inspired by.” For example, many mobile games have copied the auction-house-and-smuggling loop from Star Traders: Frontiers without permission, but they change the art and names enough to avoid lawsuits.
The Most Frequently Accused Games
Several cyberpunk trading titles have been flagged by players and reviewers as feeling “too close” to earlier games. These are the ones that come up most often in forum discussions:
- Cyberpunk 2077 (2020) — Its open-world mercenary structure and hacking minigame were compared to Deus Ex and Shadowrun Returns, but the trading element is thin, and the accusations are mostly about atmosphere, not theft.
- Neon Abyss (2020) — A roguelike with shop mechanics that many said copied Enter the Gungeon‘s item-shop layout, though the cyberpunk theme and rhythm-based combat set it apart.
- Cloudpunk (2020) — Its delivery-and-trade loop was compared to VA-11 Hall-A for dialogue style and Flashback for visual tone, but no direct cloning was proven.
- Gemini Rue (2010) — An adventure game with a trading subplot; players noticed its inventory and barter system mirrored Beneath a Steel Sky (1994) almost exactly, though the developer admitted inspiration.
- Merchant of the Skies (2021) — A trading sim with a cyberpunk DLC; its ship-upgrade and commodity-price system is nearly identical to Sunless Sea‘s, but with a different setting.
None of these were legally ruled as stolen, but the community consensus is that Gemini Rue and Merchant of the Skies come closest to crossing the line from homage to imitation.
How to Spot a Derivative Game
If you want to avoid buying a game that feels like a rip-off, look for these red flags:
- Identical UI layout — If the menu, inventory grid, and trade screen match another game pixel-for-pixel, that’s a strong sign of asset or code reuse.
- Same exact mechanics with no twist — For example, if the game uses the same buy-low/sell-high loop, same faction reputation system, and same ship stats as Elite Dangerous but changes only the names, it’s likely a clone.
- No original art or music — Check if the soundtrack or character sprites appear in other games; reverse-image search can help.
- Developer history — A studio that has released multiple “trading sim” games in a year often uses a template engine.
- Review mentions of “like X but worse” — If many reviews say it’s a worse version of a specific game, trust that.
Common Misconceptions About “Stolen” Games
One misconception is that using the same genre mechanics is theft. In reality, mechanics like “buy low, sell high,” “upgrade your ship,” or “negotiate with factions” are not copyrightable — only the specific expression (code, art, dialogue) is. So a game that plays like Star Citizen but has its own story and assets is legally fine, even if it feels derivative. Another misconception is that early access games that change drastically are “stolen” from later releases; often both are copying a common ancestor like Elite (1984) or Trade Wars (1986).
How to Choose a Genuinely Original Game
If you want a cyberpunk trading game that feels fresh, look for titles that combine trading with a unique hook. For example, VA-11 Hall-A (2016) uses bartending as the trading mechanic, Citizen Sleeper (2022) adds dice-based resource management, and Norco (2022) blends point-and-click adventure with a Southern Gothic cyberpunk setting. These games are not accused of stealing because they innovate on the core loop. When reading reviews, focus on whether the reviewer says “it’s like X” as a description or as a complaint — the former is normal, the latter is a warning.
Legal Reality: What Actually Counts as Theft
In the gaming industry, a lawsuit for “stolen” game mechanics almost never succeeds because mechanics are ideas, not expressions. For a game to be legally stolen, the plaintiff must prove that specific code, art assets, or narrative text were copied verbatim. For example, in 2012, Zynga was sued by Electronic Arts for copying The Sims Social mechanics, but the case settled out of court, and no legal precedent was set. In the cyberpunk trading niche, no notable lawsuit has ever been filed, which suggests that most accusations are fan hyperbole. The closest to a real case was Star Traders: Frontiers (2018) developers noticing a mobile clone that used their exact ship stats and event text, but they chose not to sue due to cost.
Cost and Value of Derivative Games
Derivative games are often cheaper than the originals, which is why they attract players. A clone might sell for $5 on mobile while the original is $25 on Steam. However, the lower price usually comes with less polish, fewer updates, and sometimes malware in the case of sketchy mobile ports. If you are on a budget, consider waiting for a sale on the original instead of buying a clone. For example, Sunless Sea regularly goes on sale for 75% off, making it cheaper than many copies. Also, check the refund policy — Steam allows refunds within 14 days if you have under 2 hours of playtime, which is enough time to spot a bad clone.
Alternatives to Suspect Games
If you want to avoid the “stolen” feeling entirely, here are original cyberpunk trading games that are widely praised for their uniqueness:
- VA-11 Hall-A — Bartending and dialogue, no combat.
- Citizen Sleeper — Dice-based survival and trading on a space station.
- Norco — Narrative-driven with a small but meaningful trade system.
- Cloudpunk — Delivery driving with a branching story.
- Star Traders: Frontiers — Deep simulation, but it’s the one being copied, not the copier.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it illegal to copy game mechanics?
No, game mechanics are not protected by copyright. Only the specific code, art, and text are protected. So a game that plays identically to another is legal as long as it doesn’t copy assets verbatim.
How can I tell if a game is a clone before buying?
Watch 10 minutes of gameplay on YouTube, compare the UI to the game it’s suspected of copying, and read negative reviews. If several reviews say “it’s a worse version of X,” that’s a strong signal.
Are mobile cyberpunk trading games more likely to be stolen?
Yes, mobile marketplaces have less oversight, and many developers use asset flips or copy successful Steam games. Always check the developer’s history and read recent reviews.
What should I do if I think a game stole assets from another?
Report it to the platform (Steam, App Store, etc.) with evidence like side-by-side screenshots. The original developer can also file a DMCA takedown if they own the assets.
Can a game be “inspired by” another without being a clone?
Yes, most games are inspired by others. The key difference is that an inspired game adds new mechanics, a new setting, or a new story, while a clone just reskins the original.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Reliable Subaru vs New Honda Civic Cost
- Pokemon Bookmark Corner Designs & Pokemon GO DIY
- Forgotten Games That Created Your Favorite Genres
- Lexus vs Genesis Luxurious Compact SUV0.075 hp/lb
- Uber VW Robotaxi LA Launch Date
- Notebook vs Tablet: Which Saves You More Money?