keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Why I Want More Sequels to Bad Games

Card No. 06·85773 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

I want more sequels to bad games because a flawed foundation often hides a great concept, and a sequel gives developers a second chance to realize it. When a game fails, the criticism usually points to specific problems—clunky controls, a weak story, or broken mechanics—that can be fixed while keeping the core idea that drew players in. This article explains why bad games deserve sequels, how developers can learn from failure, and what players should look for before getting excited.

The Appeal of a Second Chance

Bad games are rarely bad in every way. Most have a spark—an interesting world, a unique combat system, or a novel premise—that gets buried under execution errors. A sequel can polish that spark into a flame. For example, Assassin’s Creed (2007) was criticized for repetitive missions and a clunky control scheme, but its sequel (2009) refined the combat, added variety, and is now considered a classic. Similarly, Dead Rising 2 improved on the original’s frustrating save system and AI, making the zombie sandbox far more enjoyable. These examples show that a bad first game doesn’t mean the idea is bad; it means the execution needs work.

Players who invest time in a flawed game often develop a deep attachment to its world and characters. They want to see that world realized to its full potential. A sequel is the only way to do that without starting from scratch. It’s a form of narrative and mechanical closure that a patch or DLC can’t provide.

How Developers Learn from Failure

Game development is iterative. A sequel gives a team the chance to apply lessons learned from player feedback and internal post-mortems. Common improvements include:

  • Controls: Tightening response times, remapping buttons, or adding accessibility options.
  • Performance: Optimizing frame rates, reducing load times, and fixing crashes.
  • Story: Hiring better writers, adding branching paths, or fleshing out side characters.
  • Content: Adding more missions, modes, or multiplayer features that were missing.
  • AI: Improving enemy behavior and companion logic.

Developers also have more data to work with. They can see exactly where players quit, which weapons are most used, and which levels cause the most frustration. This data-driven approach can transform a mediocre game into a tight, engaging experience.

How to Choose Which Bad Games Deserve Sequels

Not every bad game deserves a second chance. Here are factors to consider:

  • Core concept: Is the premise original or compelling? If the idea is generic, a sequel won’t help.
  • Fixable flaws: Are the problems technical (bugs, controls) or fundamental (bad story, boring gameplay)? Technical issues are easier to fix.
  • Fan demand: Is there a vocal community asking for more? A dedicated fanbase shows there’s something worth saving.
  • Budget and scope: Did the first game sell enough to justify a sequel? Sometimes a smaller, niche follow-up is more realistic than a blockbuster.

Players can research these factors by reading reviews, watching retrospectives, and checking sales figures. A game that sold poorly but has a cult following might be a better candidate than a game that sold well but was universally panned.

Common Problems with Bad Games and Their Fixes

Here are typical issues and how sequels have addressed them:

  • Clunky controls: Darksiders II improved on the first game’s stiff combat by adding more fluid animations and a better dodge mechanic.
  • Boring missions: Just Cause 2 added a grappling hook and wingsuit, turning repetitive driving missions into chaotic fun.
  • Poor voice acting: Mass Effect 2 recast several voice actors and improved the dialogue direction, making characters more memorable.
  • Technical bugs: Batman: Arkham City fixed the PC version’s performance issues that plagued Arkham Asylum on some systems.
  • Unbalanced difficulty: Dark Souls II (while not bad) adjusted enemy placements and hitboxes after the first game’s unfair moments.

These fixes show that even major flaws can be overcome with focused effort.

Comparisons: Bad Sequels vs. Bad Originals

Sequels to bad games often face a different set of problems. They might be compared unfairly to the original’s flaws, or they might overcorrect and lose what made the first game unique. For example, Devil May Cry 2 was a sequel to a good game that was bad, and its sequel DMC: Devil May Cry (a reboot) was divisive because it changed the tone too much. On the other hand, Street Fighter V had a rough launch but improved significantly with updates and a later “Champion Edition,” showing that a bad first impression can be overcome.

When comparing, consider what the sequel keeps and what it changes. A good sequel preserves the core identity while fixing the execution. A bad sequel often abandons the original’s strengths.

Costs and Risks for Developers

Making a sequel to a bad game is risky. It requires budget, time, and a team that believes in the vision. If the first game was a commercial failure, the publisher may be reluctant to fund a sequel. However, some studios have found success with smaller budgets or crowdfunding. For example, Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night was a spiritual sequel to Castlevania: Symphony of the Night (a good game, but the point is that fans funded it). More directly, No Man’s Sky (which was considered bad at launch) received years of free updates that effectively turned it into the game that was promised, without a formal sequel. This shows that a “sequel” can be delivered as a series of patches, which is cheaper than a full new game.

Developers also risk reputation damage. If the sequel is also bad, it can cement a studio’s reputation for poor quality. But if it succeeds, it can be a redemption story that attracts players.

Safety and Ethics of Supporting Bad Games

There’s a concern that buying a bad game encourages developers to ship unfinished products, expecting to fix them later. This is a valid worry. However, there’s a difference between a game that is bad due to lack of effort and one that is bad due to ambition exceeding execution. Supporting the latter can lead to innovation. To be safe, players should:

  • Wait for reviews and patches before buying a sequel.
  • Support developers who are transparent about their plans.
  • Prefer games that offer refunds or demos.

Ethically, it’s fine to want a sequel to a bad game if you believe in the concept. Just don’t pre-order blindly.

Alternatives to Sequels

If a sequel isn’t feasible, there are other ways to revive a bad game’s idea:

  • Remakes: Rebuilding the game from the ground up (e.g., Final Fantasy VII Remake).
  • Spiritual successors: A new IP that uses similar mechanics (e.g., Yooka-Laylee for Banjo-Kazooie).
  • Mods: Community fixes that improve the original (e.g., Skyrim mods).
  • Expansions: Large DLC that adds content and fixes issues (e.g., Destiny 2: Forsaken).

These options can satisfy fans without the risk of a full sequel.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes a game “bad”?

Usually a combination of technical issues, poor design, or lack of polish. But “bad” is subjective—some players enjoy games that critics hate.

Can a sequel to a bad game be good?

Yes, many examples exist. Assassin’s Creed II, Dead Rising 2, and Just Cause 2 all improved on flawed originals.

Why do developers make sequels to bad games?

To capitalize on the original’s concept, fix mistakes, and sometimes because the first game sold well despite negative reviews.

Should I buy a sequel to a bad game?

Wait for reviews. If the sequel addresses the original’s flaws and you liked the core idea, it might be worth it.

What if the sequel is also bad?

That’s a risk. But sometimes a third game gets it right (e.g., Street Fighter V improved with updates).

Are remakes better than sequels?

It depends. Remakes can preserve the original’s identity while fixing issues, but sequels can expand the world. Both are valid.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →