NextDNS is better than Cloudflare and Quad9 for most users because it combines the privacy of a no-log resolver with powerful, user-controlled filtering, analytics, and customization that the other two services simply do not offer. While Cloudflare and Quad9 are excellent for speed and security respectively, NextDNS gives you a single dashboard to block ads, trackers, malware, and adult content, and to see exactly what your devices are querying. This article explains the key differences, how each service works, and why NextDNS’s feature set makes it the most versatile choice for home and personal use.
Background: What These DNS Resolvers Do
DNS (Domain Name System) is the internet’s phonebook. When you type a website address, your device asks a DNS resolver to translate that name into an IP address. The resolver you use can see every domain you visit, so its privacy policy and security features matter a lot.
Cloudflare’s 1.1.1.1 is known for speed and a strict no-logs policy. It does not block anything by default—it simply resolves queries as fast as possible. Quad9 (9.9.9.9) focuses on security: it blocks domains known to host malware or phishing, using threat intelligence from multiple sources. It also has a privacy-friendly policy, but it does not offer user customization.
NextDNS is a newer, cloud-based resolver that started as an ad-blocking DNS service. It lets you create a “configuration” (a profile) with your own blocklists, allowlists, and settings. You can apply that profile to your whole network, to individual devices, or even to a roaming laptop through a client app.
How NextDNS Works: Profiles, Blocklists, and Analytics
NextDNS gives you a unique DNS server address (like 1234.dns.nextdns.io) tied to your account. When you point your router or device at that address, all DNS queries go through NextDNS’s servers, where they are checked against your chosen blocklists and security feeds.
Key features that set it apart:
- Blocklists: You can enable dozens of community-maintained lists (e.g., OISD, StevenBlack, AdGuard) to block ads, trackers, gambling, social media, or adult content. Cloudflare and Quad9 have no such lists.
- Analytics: The dashboard shows a live log of every query, including which device made it, which domain was requested, and whether it was blocked. You can see what your smart TV or phone is doing in real time.
- Custom rules: You can add allow/deny rules for specific domains, or even use wildcards and regex patterns. For example, you can block
*.example.combut allowgood.example.com. - Multiple protocols: NextDNS supports DNS-over-HTTPS (DoH), DNS-over-TLS (DoT), and DNSCrypt, plus plain DNS. It also has an app for Windows, macOS, iOS, and Android that sets up a local VPN to route all traffic through your profile.
Quad9 does have a “block” list, but it is fixed and you cannot change it. Cloudflare has a separate malware-blocking IP (1.1.1.2) and adult-content-blocking IP (1.1.1.3), but those are simple on/off switches, not customizable filters.
Privacy and Logging: What Each Service Keeps
All three services claim to be privacy-friendly, but their logging policies differ significantly.
Cloudflare states it does not log IP addresses and only keeps minimal metadata for operational purposes (like which data center handled the query). Quad9 also does not collect IP addresses and logs only the domain name and approximate location (city-level) for threat research, with a 24-hour retention period.
NextDNS, by default, logs your queries on your dashboard so you can see them. However, you can turn off logging entirely or set a retention period (e.g., 1 hour, 1 day, 1 week). If you disable logging, NextDNS still processes the query but does not store it. This is a trade-off: you get analytics only if you allow logs, but you have full control over that data. Cloudflare and Quad9 give you no such control—their logging policies are fixed.
Security and Malware Blocking: Quad9’s Edge, NextDNS’s Flexibility
Quad9’s primary selling point is its security blocklist, which is aggregated from several threat intelligence partners. It blocks domains that are known to be malicious, often before they appear in other lists. For a purely security-focused resolver, Quad9 is excellent and very effective.
NextDNS also includes security feeds (like Threat Intelligence, Cryptojacking, and DNS Rebinding protection) that you can toggle on. But because you can add your own blocklists, you can combine security and privacy filtering in one place. For example, you can enable OISD (a huge list that blocks ads and trackers) plus the security feed, giving you both protection and ad-blocking.
Cloudflare’s 1.1.1.2 (malware blocking) uses its own threat data, but it is less comprehensive than Quad9’s aggregated list. Cloudflare also offers “1.1.1.1 for Families” with these filters, but again, no customization.
Speed and Performance: Cloudflare Leads, but NextDNS Is Close
Cloudflare is widely regarded as the fastest public DNS resolver due to its massive anycast network and optimized infrastructure. In many benchmarks, it has the lowest average response time. Quad9 and NextDNS are also fast, but may be slightly slower depending on your location and network.
NextDNS uses anycast routing and has servers in many regions, but because it performs more processing (checking blocklists, logging, etc.), its latency can be a few milliseconds higher. For most users, this difference is imperceptible. If you are a gamer or run a high-frequency trading setup, you might notice a tiny difference, but for normal browsing, streaming, and video calls, all three are fine.
One speed advantage NextDNS has: it caches DNS responses aggressively, and you can enable “CNAME flattening” and “Anonymized EDNS Client Subnet” to improve performance while preserving privacy.
Customization and Control: The Core Advantage
This is where NextDNS is clearly better. Cloudflare and Quad9 are “set and forget” services—you change your DNS server and that’s it. NextDNS is more like a mini firewall for your DNS traffic.
Examples of what you can do with NextDNS that you cannot do with the others:
- Block specific device types (e.g., block all queries from your smart TV except for streaming services).
- Create multiple profiles for different networks (home, work, mobile) with different rules.
- Set a “block page” that shows a message when a site is blocked, instead of just failing to resolve.
- Use “Denylist” and “Allowlist” to override blocklists for specific domains.
- View a breakdown of blocked queries by category (ads, trackers, malware, etc.).
For families, this means you can block adult content on your kids’ devices while still allowing YouTube or other sites. For tech enthusiasts, you can monitor every device on your network and spot suspicious activity (like a smart device phoning home).
Cost and Free Tier: NextDNS’s Generous Model
Cloudflare and Quad9 are completely free with no premium tiers. NextDNS also has a free tier that allows up to 300,000 queries per month. For a typical household, that is roughly 10,000 queries per day, which is usually enough for a few devices. If you exceed that, you can upgrade to a paid plan (about $2 per month) for unlimited queries and more features like multi-device support.
For most home users, the free tier is sufficient. If you have a large family or many IoT devices, the paid plan is still cheaper than a coffee per month. This pricing model is fair and makes NextDNS accessible to everyone.
Common Problems and How to Avoid Them
One common issue with NextDNS is over-blocking. Some blocklists are aggressive and can break websites that rely on third-party scripts. For example, a site might not load if its CDN is blocked. The fix is to check the logs, find the blocked domain, and add it to your allowlist. This is a learning curve that Cloudflare and Quad9 do not have because they do not block anything (except Quad9’s security list, which rarely over-blocks).
Another issue is that NextDNS requires you to set up a profile and point your devices to its DNS servers. If you only change your router’s DNS, devices that use their own DNS (like some smart TVs or mobile apps) may bypass it. The NextDNS client app solves this by creating a local VPN, but it uses battery on mobile devices.
Finally, if you disable logging for privacy, you lose the analytics that make NextDNS useful. You need to find a balance—many users keep logs for 24 hours and then auto-delete.
How to Choose: Which One Should You Use?
Here is a simple guide:
- Choose Cloudflare if you want the absolute fastest resolver and do not care about blocking anything.
- Choose Quad9 if you want strong malware protection and do not want to configure anything.
- Choose NextDNS if you want ad-blocking, parental controls, analytics, and customization—and you are willing to spend 15 minutes setting it up.
If you are a privacy advocate, you might prefer Cloudflare or Quad9 because they have simpler logging policies. But if you are a home user with kids, smart devices, or just tired of ads, NextDNS is the clear winner.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does NextDNS slow down my internet?
No. DNS resolution is only a tiny part of your overall connection. Even if NextDNS adds a few milliseconds, you will not notice it in normal use. The only time you might see a slowdown is if you enable many heavy blocklists, but even then, the impact is minimal.
Can I use NextDNS alongside a VPN?
Yes, but you need to configure your VPN to use NextDNS’s DNS servers, or use NextDNS’s app which creates a local VPN. If your VPN forces its own DNS, NextDNS will not work. Many commercial VPNs allow you to set custom DNS servers.
Is NextDNS really private if it logs my queries?
By default, logs are visible only to you, and you can disable them entirely. NextDNS’s privacy policy states it does not sell data and does not track you across sites. The logs are for your own use, not for advertising.
Can I block YouTube ads with NextDNS?
No. YouTube serves ads from the same domain as the video content, so DNS-based blocking cannot distinguish between the two. You would need a browser extension or a different method. NextDNS can block trackers and other ads, but not YouTube’s in-stream ads.
What happens if NextDNS goes down?
If NextDNS’s servers are unreachable, your device will fall back to your ISP’s DNS or the next configured server. This means you might temporarily lose ad-blocking, but you will not lose internet access. You can set up a secondary DNS server (like Cloudflare) as a backup.
Do I need to install software to use NextDNS?
No. You can simply change your router’s DNS settings to the NextDNS server address. However, installing the client app gives you extra features like per-device configuration and automatic setup on mobile.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Skip Ryobi and Milwaukee? Harbor Freight Tools to Buy
- Funny Subreddits That Make You Laugh
- Why Retro Gaming Is Still Worth Playing Today
- Neptune Facts That Will Blow Your Mind
- Survival Crafting Game Fatigue: Why & How to Fix It
- Sell Your EV Now Before Prices Plummet?