keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Why side missions and player choices make open world stories feel deeper?

Card No. 06·80599 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Side missions and player choices make open world stories feel deeper because they transform the player from a passive observer into an active participant whose actions have visible, lasting consequences across a living world. Instead of a single linear path, the narrative becomes a web of interconnected threads that the player personally weaves, creating a sense of ownership and investment that a straightforward main questline cannot replicate.

How Side Missions Build Narrative Texture

Side missions add depth by giving the world its own stories, independent of the main plot. A main quest typically follows a hero’s journey—defeat the villain, save the kingdom. Side missions, however, explore the lives of ordinary people: a blacksmith losing his daughter, a guard haunted by a past mistake, a farmer dealing with a corrupt noble. These smaller stories create emotional resonance because they feel personal and relatable. They also make the world seem populated by individuals with their own goals and problems, rather than cardboard cutouts waiting for the player to advance a script.

For example, in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, a seemingly simple contract to kill a monster often unravels into a moral dilemma with no clear right answer. The player’s choice—spare the monster, kill it, or punish the client—affects the local population and future encounters. This kind of narrative density is impossible in a linear game where every scene must serve the main plot.

Player Choice as a Narrative Engine

Choice deepens stories by making the player co-author the narrative. When a game presents a meaningful decision—save a village or pursue a personal vendetta, betray an ally or stay loyal—it forces the player to reflect on their own values. The story becomes personal because the player caused the outcome, not because a writer dictated it.

Games like Mass Effect and Fallout: New Vegas are built on this principle. The choices you make in side quests can alter the political landscape of the entire game world, determining which factions rise or fall. This creates a feedback loop: the player sees the consequences of their actions, which makes subsequent choices feel weightier. The narrative depth comes not from the number of branching paths, but from the emotional weight attached to each decision.

How Open Worlds Amplify the Effect

An open world provides the spatial and temporal freedom that side missions and choices need to flourish. In a linear game, a choice is a one-off event; in an open world, you can revisit the site of a decision and see its aftermath. A village you saved from bandits might later prosper, with new shops and NPCs. A character you spared might appear again, offering help or seeking revenge. This persistence makes the world feel reactive and alive.

Open worlds also allow for environmental storytelling—notes, audio logs, and scenery that hint at past events. When combined with player agency, these elements create a layered narrative where the player’s actions become part of the world’s history. The world doesn’t just tell a story; it remembers the player’s story.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

One common misconception is that more choices automatically mean a deeper story. In reality, choices only matter if they have meaningful consequences. A dialogue option that changes a single line of text but leads to the same outcome feels shallow. True depth requires that choices alter the narrative in observable ways, whether through character relationships, world state, or ending variations.

Another problem is the “illusion of choice”—when the game presents a decision but railroads the player to the same result. This can feel deceptive and undermine trust. Developers must carefully balance branching narratives to avoid overwhelming themselves while still delivering genuine agency.

Additionally, side missions can feel like filler if they are repetitive or disconnected from the main themes. A fetch quest that has no bearing on the world’s lore or the player’s character adds nothing. The best side missions are those that echo the main story’s themes or offer a different perspective on the world’s conflicts.

How to Choose Which Side Missions to Do

Not all side content is created equal. Players often wonder which missions are worth their time. Here are some practical guidelines:

  • Look for unique rewards – missions that offer special gear, abilities, or lore are usually more substantial.
  • Check for named NPCs – if a mission involves a character with a name and a backstory, it likely has more narrative weight than a generic “kill 10 wolves” task.
  • Follow your curiosity – if a side quest aligns with your character’s moral compass or interests, it will feel more meaningful.
  • Don’t ignore the world – sometimes the best stories are hidden in unmarked locations or triggered by exploring off the beaten path.

Ultimately, the “right” side missions are those that resonate with you personally. The beauty of open world design is that you can skip the ones that feel like chores and focus on those that enrich your experience.

Comparison: Linear vs. Open World Narrative Depth

Linear games like The Last of Us deliver deep stories through tightly scripted scenes and character development. Open world games sacrifice some of that narrative focus for player freedom. The depth in open world games comes from breadth—many small stories that interweave—rather than a single, concentrated arc.

Both approaches have merits. Linear games can craft precise emotional beats because the player has no control over the pacing. Open world games offer a different kind of depth: the feeling that the story is yours, shaped by your decisions. The best open world games, such as Red Dead Redemption 2 or Cyberpunk 2077, manage to combine both—a strong main narrative with side content that enriches it rather than distracts from it.

Safety and Ethical Considerations in Game Design

While this topic doesn’t involve physical safety, there are design ethics to consider. Games that offer choices must be careful not to punish players unfairly for decisions they couldn’t foresee. A choice that leads to a catastrophic outcome without any warning can feel cheap. Good design provides enough information for the player to make an informed decision, even if the outcome is surprising.

Additionally, developers should avoid reinforcing harmful stereotypes through side missions or choices. A mission that forces the player to choose between two equally bad options can be powerful, but only if the moral complexity is handled with nuance. The goal is to make the player think, not to simply shock them.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do side missions affect the main story?

In many open world games, yes. Some side missions unlock allies, resources, or information that directly help in the main quest. Others may alter the ending or the fate of certain characters. However, in some games, side missions are purely optional and have no impact on the main narrative—they exist only for world-building and rewards.

Why do some choices feel meaningless?

This usually happens when the game presents a binary choice but both options lead to the same outcome, or when the consequences are so minor they’re barely noticeable. Meaningful choices require the game to track the player’s decisions and reflect them in the world, which is technically demanding. Some developers cut corners to save time, leading to the “illusion of choice.”

How many side missions should I do before finishing the main story?

There’s no right answer. If you’re enjoying the side content, do as much as you like. If you’re worried about over-leveling and making the main quest too easy, you can skip some or adjust the difficulty. Most games are designed so that you can complete the main story without doing any side missions, but you’ll miss out on a lot of depth.

Can side missions be better than the main story?

Absolutely. In many games, side missions are where writers take more creative risks because they don’t have to advance the main plot. They can explore quirky characters, moral dilemmas, or tragic backstories. Some of the most memorable moments in gaming come from side quests, like the Bloody Baron questline in The Witcher 3 or the Vault experiments in Fallout.

What makes a side mission “good”?

A good side mission has a clear objective, a compelling narrative hook, and a meaningful reward—whether that’s a new item, a piece of lore, or an emotional payoff. It should feel like it belongs in the world, not like a random fetch quest. The best side missions are those that you remember long after you’ve finished the game.

Do open world games with more choices always have deeper stories?

Not necessarily. Depth comes from the quality of the choices and their consequences, not the quantity. A game with three well-designed choices that significantly alter the narrative is deeper than one with fifty choices that all lead to the same ending. The key is that the player feels their decisions matter.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →