The Asus Zenfone Max Pro M2 (6GB) and the Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 Pro are both strong budget phones, but the Zenfone Max Pro wins for battery life and stock Android, while the Redmi Note 5 Pro wins for camera quality and MIUI features. If you value two-day endurance and a clean interface, choose the Zenfone; if you prefer better low-light photos and a more feature-rich UI, choose the Redmi.
Background: The 2018 Budget King Battle
In early 2018, the Redmi Note 5 Pro set a new standard for budget phones with its dual cameras and Snapdragon 636 chip. Asus responded with the Zenfone Max Pro M1, which offered a massive 5000mAh battery and near-stock Android at a lower price. The 6GB RAM variants of both phones were the top configurations of their generation, aimed at users who wanted more multitasking headroom without paying flagship prices. Both devices became popular in markets like India and Southeast Asia, where value-for-money is a primary buying factor.
Key Specs at a Glance
- Display: Both have a 5.99-inch Full HD+ (2160×1080) IPS LCD with a 18:9 aspect ratio.
- Processor: Both use the Snapdragon 636 octa-core CPU, so everyday performance is nearly identical.
- RAM/Storage: Both come in 6GB RAM with 64GB storage, expandable via microSD.
- Battery: Zenfone Max Pro M1 has 5000mAh; Redmi Note 5 Pro has 4000mAh.
- Rear Cameras: Zenfone: 13MP+5MP; Redmi: 12MP+5MP (Sony IMX486 sensor).
- Front Camera: Zenfone: 8MP; Redmi: 20MP.
- OS: Zenfone runs Android 8.1 (upgradable to 10); Redmi runs MIUI 9 based on Android 8.1 (upgradable to 10).
Battery and Charging: The Biggest Difference
The Zenfone Max Pro M1’s 5000mAh battery is its headline feature. In real-world use, it easily lasts two days with moderate use—streaming, social media, and calls. The Redmi Note 5 Pro’s 4000mAh battery is still good for a full day, but heavy users may need to charge by evening. Both phones charge via micro-USB, but the Zenfone supports 5V/2A charging (10W) while the Redmi supports Qualcomm Quick Charge 3.0 (up to 18W) if you use a compatible charger. However, the Redmi’s included charger is only 10W, so you’ll need to buy a QC3.0 adapter to get faster speeds. The Zenfone’s larger battery means it takes longer to fully charge (about 2.5 hours with the included adapter), but you’ll charge less often.
Software Experience: Stock vs MIUI
The Zenfone Max Pro runs near-stock Android with minimal bloatware. It’s clean, fast, and gets quicker updates (it received Android 10). The Redmi Note 5 Pro runs MIUI, which is heavily customized with themes, gestures, and built-in apps like Mi Browser and Mi Store. MIUI offers more features (dual apps, second space, extensive customization), but it also shows ads in some system apps (you can disable them). If you prefer a pure Android experience, the Zenfone is the clear choice; if you like customization and don’t mind some extra apps, MIUI is fine. The Zenfone also has a dedicated microSD slot (hybrid in the Redmi), so you can use two SIMs and a memory card simultaneously.
Camera Comparison: Redmi Takes the Lead
The Redmi Note 5 Pro’s 12MP rear camera (with 1.25μm pixel size) captures sharper, more detailed photos in good light and performs notably better in low light. The Zenfone Max Pro’s 13MP camera is decent for daylight shots but struggles in dim conditions—photos can be soft and noisy. The Redmi’s 20MP front camera is also superior for selfies, with better skin tones and a portrait mode that works reasonably well. The Zenfone’s 8MP front camera is average. If photography is a priority, the Redmi Note 5 Pro is the better choice.
Performance and Gaming
Both phones use the same Snapdragon 636 chip and 6GB RAM, so performance in everyday apps and multitasking is nearly identical. In games like PUBG Mobile (now BGMI) and Call of Duty, both can run at medium settings with stable frame rates. The Zenfone’s larger battery gives it a slight edge for long gaming sessions, as it won’t drain as quickly. However, the Redmi’s MIUI has a Game Turbo mode that optimizes performance and blocks notifications, which some gamers prefer. In synthetic benchmarks, both score around 115,000 on AnTuTu (v7), so there’s no real winner in raw speed.
Build Quality and Extras
Both phones have a metal unibody design, but the Redmi Note 5 Pro feels slightly more premium with its curved edges and better weight distribution. The Zenfone Max Pro is a bit thicker (8.45mm vs 8.05mm) due to the larger battery, but it’s still comfortable to hold. Neither has a USB-C port, NFC, or a notification LED (the Zenfone has a small LED, the Redmi does not). The Redmi has a faster fingerprint sensor and supports face unlock (though less secure). The Zenfone has a dedicated microSD slot and a 3.5mm headphone jack, which the Redmi also has. Overall, build quality is comparable, but the Redmi feels slightly more refined.
Price and Availability
At launch, the 6GB/64GB Zenfone Max Pro M1 was priced around ₹14,999 (approximately $200), while the Redmi Note 5 Pro 6GB/64GB was ₹16,999 (approximately $230). Prices have dropped since, and both are often available for under $150 in the used market. Availability varies by region; the Redmi Note 5 Pro was more widely sold in India, while the Zenfone had a stronger presence in Taiwan and some Southeast Asian markets. For current pricing, check local online retailers or second-hand platforms.
Common Problems and How to Avoid Them
- Zenfone Max Pro: Some users report GPS issues (fixed in later updates) and a slightly dim display. The camera is the weakest point—avoid it if you take many low-light photos.
- Redmi Note 5 Pro: MIUI ads can be annoying; disable them via Settings > Additional settings > Privacy > Ad services. Some units have a yellowish tint on the display; adjust color temperature in display settings.
- Both: Micro-USB ports can wear out over time; use a magnetic cable or be gentle when plugging in.
How to Choose: A Simple Checklist
- Battery life: If you need two days of use, pick the Zenfone.
- Camera: If you take lots of photos, especially at night, pick the Redmi.
- Software: If you want a clean Android experience, pick the Zenfone; if you like customization, pick the Redmi.
- Price: If the Zenfone is cheaper in your region, it’s the better value; if the Redmi is close in price, it’s worth the extra for the camera.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which phone has better battery life? The Zenfone Max Pro M1 with its 5000mAh battery easily lasts two days, while the Redmi Note 5 Pro’s 4000mAh battery lasts about a day and a half with moderate use.
Does the Redmi Note 5 Pro have a better camera than the Zenfone Max Pro? Yes, the Redmi’s 12MP Sony sensor captures more detail and performs better in low light. The 20MP front camera also produces sharper selfies than the Zenfone’s 8MP.
Can I use two SIM cards and a microSD card on both phones? On the Zenfone, yes—it has a dedicated microSD slot. On the Redmi, you must choose between a second SIM or a microSD card (hybrid slot).
Which phone gets Android 10 updates? Both phones received Android 10 updates, but the Zenfone’s stock Android update was cleaner and arrived faster. The Redmi’s MIUI 11/12 update also brought Android 10, but with more bloatware.
Is the Zenfone Max Pro good for gaming? Yes, the Snapdragon 636 and 6GB RAM handle most games at medium settings. The large battery gives it an advantage for extended gaming sessions.
Which phone is more durable? Both have metal bodies and are similar in build quality. The Redmi feels slightly more premium, but the Zenfone’s thicker body may offer better drop protection due to more material.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Skip Ryobi and Milwaukee? Harbor Freight Tools to Buy
- Funny Subreddits That Make You Laugh
- Why Retro Gaming Is Still Worth Playing Today
- KDE Connect Vulnerabilities: Are These Versions at Risk?
- Neptune Facts That Will Blow Your Mind
- Survival Crafting Game Fatigue: Why & How to Fix It