If you finished Assassin’s Creed Valhalla and want more of that open-world, RPG-style stealth and combat, the top pick is Assassin’s Creed Odyssey. It shares the most DNA with Valhalla—huge map, dialogue choices, ability trees, and naval combat—while swapping Viking raids for ancient Greece. It feels familiar enough to jump into immediately, but distinct enough to keep things fresh.
What to Look For
When picking your next AC game after Valhalla, focus on these criteria:
- Combat & RPG mechanics: Valhalla is an action-RPG with skill trees, gear upgrades, and stamina-based combat. Older games (pre-Origins) play very differently, so decide if you want that same style or a change.
- World size & exploration: Valhalla’s England is massive. If you loved that, Origins and Odyssey offer similarly huge maps. If you want something tighter, the older games are more compact.
- Stealth vs. brawling: Valhalla lets you go loud or stealthy. Some AC games lean harder into social stealth (crowds, blending) while others are more action-focused.
- Story & setting: Do you want more Viking-era content, or are you ready for a new time period? Egypt, Greece, and Revolutionary America all offer distinct tones.
- Modern-day vs. historical: If you cared about the present-day narrative, the newer games (Origins through Mirage) have a different framing than the older ones.
Assassin’s Creed Odyssey
Strengths: The most Valhalla-like experience. Massive open world (Greece), naval combat, dialogue choices that affect the story, and an ability system that lets you specialize in warrior, assassin, or hunter. The combat feels fluid and responsive, and the world is gorgeous.
Trade-offs: The story can feel bloated with side quests, and the level-gating can force grinding. The protagonist (Alexios or Kassandra) is more of a mercenary than a hidden one, so stealth is less central.
Who it suits: Players who want more of the same formula with a new setting, and who enjoyed the RPG elements of Valhalla more than the Viking fantasy itself.
Assassin’s Creed Origins
Strengths: This is the game that started the modern RPG direction. Set in Ptolemaic Egypt, it has a more focused story about Bayek and Aya, a beautiful desert world, and a combat system that feels weighty and deliberate. The setting is stunning and the main quest is tighter than Odyssey’s.
Trade-offs: The RPG mechanics are less refined than Valhalla’s—fewer abilities, simpler gear system. Naval combat is minimal (just a few ship sections). The map is big but emptier than Greece or England.
Who it suits: Players who want a more personal, character-driven story and are interested in the origins of the Assassin Brotherhood. Good if you found Valhalla’s side content overwhelming.
Assassin’s Creed Mirage
Strengths: A return to the classic formula—smaller city (Baghdad), focus on stealth, parkour, and assassination contracts. It’s a direct spiritual successor to the original AC games, with a tighter 20-30 hour campaign. If you missed the social stealth and hidden blade gameplay, this is it.
Trade-offs: The combat is simpler and less RPG-like. No dialogue choices, no skill trees, and the world is much smaller. If you loved Valhalla’s raids and settlement building, you won’t find that here.
Who it suits: Players who want a break from the 100+ hour epics and prefer a focused, stealth-first experience. Also great if you want to understand the modern-day framing better.
Assassin’s Creed IV: Black Flag
Strengths: The best naval combat in the series. You captain a pirate ship, explore the Caribbean, and engage in sea battles that feel thrilling. The open world is large and the pirate fantasy is well-executed. It also has a strong story with Edward Kenway.
Trade-offs: It’s an older game (2013), so the combat is more counter-based and the parkour is less fluid than Valhalla. The modern-day segments are dated, and the stealth mechanics are basic.
Who it suits: Players who loved the naval sections of Valhalla and want more ship-to-ship combat. Also good for those who want a more linear, story-driven experience without RPG grinding.
Assassin’s Creed Syndicate
Strengths: Set in Victorian London, this one has a fun grappling hook that makes traversal quick and enjoyable. The dual protagonists (Jacob and Evie) offer different playstyles, and the city is dense with activities. It’s a good middle ground between old and new AC.
Trade-offs: The combat is simple and the RPG elements are minimal. The story is lighter and less epic than Valhalla’s. The world feels smaller and more urban.
Who it suits: Players who want a shorter, more arcade-like AC game with a great setting, and who don’t mind a step back in graphics and mechanics.
Assassin’s Creed Rogue
Strengths: The only game where you play as a Templar. Set between Black Flag and AC III, it offers a unique perspective and a compact but varied world (North Atlantic, New York). Naval combat is refined from Black Flag, and the story is surprisingly engaging.
Trade-offs: It’s short (around 10-15 hours), and the gameplay is essentially a reskin of Black Flag with some tweaks. The graphics and mechanics are dated.
Who it suits: Completionists who want to see the full colonial-era arc, or players who want a quick AC fix without committing to a 60-hour epic.
How to Choose
First, decide your budget. If you’re buying new, Odyssey and Origins are often discounted and offer the most content per dollar. Mirage is newer and pricier but shorter. Older games like Black Flag and Rogue are usually very cheap, especially on sale.
Next, consider your use case. If you have limited time, go with Mirage or Rogue. If you want a long-term commitment, Odyssey or Origins. If you want the closest experience to Valhalla, Odyssey is the safest bet. If you want a change of pace, try Black Flag for naval or Mirage for stealth.
Common trade-offs: Newer games have better graphics and mechanics but can feel bloated. Older games are tighter but feel dated. Also, note that the modern-day story is more prominent in the older games (Black Flag, Rogue) while the newer ones (Origins, Odyssey, Mirage) treat it as a side element.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can I play Odyssey after Valhalla without feeling repetitive?
A: Yes, because the setting and story are different enough, but the gameplay loop is nearly identical. If you’re burned out on the formula, take a break with Mirage or Black Flag.
Q: Is Mirage a full game or DLC?
A: It’s a full standalone game, but it’s shorter and more focused. It’s about 20-30 hours, similar to the original AC games.
Q: Which AC game has the best naval combat after Valhalla?
A: Black Flag is the gold standard for naval combat. Odyssey also has good naval battles, but Black Flag’s are more central to the game.
Q: Do I need to play the older games to understand the modern-day story?
A: Not really. Each game’s modern-day segments are self-contained enough, but playing Black Flag and Rogue will give you more context on the overarching conflict.
Q: Which game is the most similar to Valhalla in terms of combat?
A: Odyssey. It has the same stamina-based, ability-driven combat. Origins is similar but a bit clunkier.
Q: Is there a game that combines the old and new styles?
A: Syndicate is a good bridge—it has some RPG elements but retains the classic structure. Mirage is also a hybrid, but leans more toward the old style.
Bottom Line
For most players, Assassin’s Creed Odyssey is the clear next step after Valhalla—it’s the same formula with a better setting and more player choice. If you want a change of pace, pick Mirage for stealth or Black Flag for naval. And if you want to see where the modern RPG style began, Origins is a fantastic, focused experience. Whichever you choose, you’re getting a solid open-world adventure.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Car Trends Making Cars Worse: 7 Downsides
- Nostalgic Classic Games Revamped on G2A?
- Nvidia RTX 4000 Super GPUs: Full Specs & Buying Guide
- Photoshop vs Lightroom AI Features Compared
- DNF vs DNF5: Which Package Manager?
- Korean SUV Making BMW and Audi Owners Question Their Choices?