keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Best Story-Driven RPGs to Play After The Witcher 3

Card No. 06·82597 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

If you finished The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt and crave more games where narrative is the core, the top pick is Disco Elysium. It matches the Witcher’s deep character writing and morally gray choices, but replaces combat with a revolutionary dialogue system where your skills, thoughts, and failures shape the story. It’s the only game that made me feel the same weight of every decision, even though it has no swords or monsters.

What to Look For

When you’re hunting for the next story-first RPG, these are the criteria that actually matter:

  • Choice & Consequence: Do your decisions meaningfully change the plot, characters, or world? The Witcher 3 is famous for side quests that ripple into the ending. Look for games that track your actions and reference them later.
  • Character Depth: Are the companions and NPCs written with believable motivations, flaws, and arcs? A strong antagonist is just as important as a likable protagonist.
  • Worldbuilding & Lore: A rich, consistent setting that rewards exploration and reading. The Witcher’s Slavic-inspired world is dense with history; you want something that feels just as lived-in.
  • Moral Ambiguity: Avoid games with clear-cut good/evil choices. The best stories make you question your own decisions, just like the Baron’s questline did.
  • Pacing & Side Content: Look for games where side quests are as compelling as the main story, not just filler. Also consider whether the game respects your time (no pointless fetch quests).

Disco Elysium

Strengths: Unparalleled writing and role-playing freedom. You play as a detective with amnesia, and your stats are your personality traits that literally talk to you. Every conversation is a skill check, and failure often leads to better outcomes. The world of Revachol is politically complex and deeply human.

Trade-offs: No combat, no traditional exploration, and it’s almost entirely text-based (though fully voice-acted in the Final Cut). The setting is modern-fantasy, not medieval, and the tone is more absurdist and philosophical than grimdark.

Who it suits: Players who loved the Witcher’s dialogue trees and moral dilemmas but want something even more cerebral. If you’re okay with reading a lot and letting your character’s weaknesses drive the narrative, this is a masterpiece.

Cyberpunk 2077 (with Phantom Liberty)

Strengths: From the same studio as The Witcher 3, this is the closest in structure: open world, dense side jobs, and a branching main story. The Phantom Liberty expansion is a spy-thriller with some of the best-written quests in any RPG, and the 2.0 update fixed most launch issues. The world of Night City is a character itself, and the companion characters (Johnny Silverhand, Judy, Panam) have arcs that rival Yen and Ciri.

Trade-offs: The main story is shorter than TW3, and some choices feel less impactful on the world (though they hugely affect your ending). The first-person perspective may take getting used to, and the open world can be overwhelming.

Who it suits: Witcher fans who want a similar “big open world + personal story” feel but with guns and cyberware. If you liked Gwent, you’ll love the braindance investigations.

Dragon Age: Origins

Strengths: The gold standard for party-based storytelling. Your origin story (human noble, elf mage, dwarf commoner, etc.) changes the first few hours and how the world reacts to you. The companions are memorable, and the choices you make—from who rules a kingdom to who lives or dies—have serious consequences. The dark fantasy tone is very close to the Witcher.

Trade-offs: It’s older (2009), so the graphics and combat feel dated. The tactical combat is more complex than TW3’s, and the pacing is slower. The sequel, Dragon Age: Inquisition, is more modern but less tightly written.

Who it suits: Players who loved the Witcher’s political intrigue and party banter. If you’re okay with older mechanics for a richer story, this is essential.

Kingdom Come: Deliverance

Strengths: The most immersive medieval RPG ever made. You play as Henry, a blacksmith’s son, in 15th-century Bohemia. There is no magic, no monsters—just realistic history. The story is grounded and personal, and your choices genuinely affect how people treat you. The side quests are handcrafted and often have multiple solutions.

Trade-offs: The combat is notoriously difficult and takes real practice. The game is unforgiving in its realism (you can’t read at first, you get hungry, you need to sleep). The main story is slower and less epic than the Witcher’s.

Who it suits: Players who want a grounded, historical story with a strong sense of place. If you enjoyed the gritty realism of Velen and Novigrad, this will scratch that itch.

Baldur’s Gate 3

Strengths: The closest thing to a true “your choices matter” RPG. Based on D&D 5e, it offers unmatched reactivity: you can talk your way out of almost any fight, and the companions have deep personal quests that intertwine with the main plot. The voice acting and motion capture are top-tier, and the story is a dark, epic journey with multiple endings.

Trade-offs: It’s turn-based, which is a big departure from real-time combat. The first act is massive and can be overwhelming, and the dice-roll mechanics may frustrate players who prefer action. It’s also more mature in content than the Witcher.

Who it suits: Players who want the most reactive story possible and don’t mind turn-based combat. If you loved the Witcher’s side quests that feel like mini-stories, BG3 is full of them.

Mass Effect Legendary Edition

Strengths: A trilogy that carries your choices across all three games. Commander Shepard’s story is epic in scope, and the companions (Garrus, Tali, Liara) are some of the most beloved in gaming. The worldbuilding is rich, and the moral choices (Paragon/Renegade) are more nuanced than they first appear. The Legendary Edition includes all DLC and visual upgrades.

Trade-offs: The first game, Mass Effect 1, feels dated in mechanics (vehicle sections, inventory). The story is more sci-fi than fantasy, and the choices are more binary than the Witcher’s gray morality.

Who it suits: Players who want a long, character-driven saga with a strong central protagonist. If you liked the “found family” aspect of the Witcher, you’ll love the Normandy crew.

How to Choose

Your budget and time will often decide. If you want a modern, open-world experience with high production values, Cyberpunk 2077 is the safest bet. If you’re okay with older graphics and want the deepest party interactions, Dragon Age: Origins is cheap and often on sale. For a completely different take on storytelling, Disco Elysium is a low-cost, high-reward option (it’s frequently discounted).

Consider your tolerance for combat. Baldur’s Gate 3 and Dragon Age: Origins are turn-based/tactical; Kingdom Come has a steep learning curve; Cyberpunk and Mass Effect are action-focused. If you want to avoid combat entirely, Disco Elysium is the only one with zero combat.

Also think about setting. Do you want more medieval fantasy? Kingdom Come or Dragon Age. Sci-fi? Mass Effect or Cyberpunk. Something unique? Disco Elysium or Baldur’s Gate (which is high fantasy but with a fresh twist).

A common trade-off is choice vs. polish. Baldur’s Gate 3 offers the most reactivity but requires patience. Cyberpunk 2077 is more polished but your choices have less impact on the world. Decide what matters more to you.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are any of these games as long as The Witcher 3?

Cyberpunk 2077 is comparable in length (about 60-80 hours for main + side content). Baldur’s Gate 3 can be even longer (100+ hours). Disco Elysium is shorter (20-30 hours) but very dense.

Do I need to play the previous games in a series?

For Dragon Age: Origins, you can start fresh. For Mass Effect Legendary Edition, you start with the first game, so no prior knowledge needed. Cyberpunk and Disco Elysium are standalone. Baldur’s Gate 3 is set in the same world but is a new story, so you can jump in.

Which game has the best romance options?

Cyberpunk 2077 and Baldur’s Gate 3 have the most detailed and well-written romances. Dragon Age: Origins also has strong romances, but they’re more dated.

I hated the combat in The Witcher 3. What should I play?

Disco Elysium has no combat at all. Cyberpunk 2077’s combat is more fluid and can be avoided with stealth/dialogue. Mass Effect’s combat is simple and shooter-based.

Are there any games with a similar “monster hunter” feel?

Not exactly, but the closest is Dragon Age: Origins (darkspawn instead of monsters) and Baldur’s Gate 3 (various creatures). If you want a monster-hunting story, check out the Horizon series (Zero Dawn/Forbidden West), though it’s more action-adventure than RPG.

Which game has the best villain?

Baldur’s Gate 3 has a compelling antagonist in the Absolute. Mass Effect’s Saren is iconic. Disco Elysium’s villain is more of a concept than a person.

Bottom Line

For most Witcher fans, Cyberpunk 2077 (with Phantom Liberty) is the most natural next step—same studio, same narrative DNA, but a fresh world. If you want the absolute best writing and don’t mind a slower pace, Disco Elysium is the critical darling you shouldn’t miss. And if you want a game that truly respects your choices, Baldur’s Gate 3 is the modern masterpiece. Start with the one that matches your preferred setting and combat style, and you won’t be disappointed.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →