Enshrouded and Valheim are both excellent survival RPGs, but for solo and co-op play, Valheim is the more polished and complete experience, while Enshrouded offers a more modern, story-driven take with better building tools. Your choice ultimately depends on whether you prioritize a vast, procedurally generated world with deep exploration (Valheim) or a handcrafted, quest-filled realm with more accessible combat and construction (Enshrouded).
Background: The Two Contenders
Valheim, released in Early Access in February 2021 by the Swedish studio Iron Gate, took the gaming world by storm, selling millions of copies within weeks. It blends Viking mythology with survival mechanics, procedural world generation, and a distinctive low-poly art style that belies its atmospheric depth. Players are a fallen Viking warrior who must prove their worth to enter Valhalla by defeating the Forsaken bosses.
Enshrouded, developed by Keen Games (known for the Portal Knights series) and released in Early Access in January 2024, is a more recent entrant. It features a handcrafted world called Embervale, which has been ravaged by a magical pestilence called the Shroud. The game emphasizes a story-driven experience with NPCs, quests, and a skill tree system, alongside a robust building system that allows for voxel-based construction and terraforming.
Both games support up to 10 players in co-op (Valheim) and 16 players (Enshrouded), but both are perfectly playable solo. The core loop in both is similar: gather resources, craft gear, build a base, and fight bosses. However, the execution and focus differ significantly.
Gameplay and Progression: How They Work
Valheim’s progression is entirely boss-driven and biome-gated. You start in the Meadows, a relatively safe grassland, and must defeat Eikthyr, the first boss, to unlock the ability to mine certain ores. Each subsequent biome (Black Forest, Swamp, Mountains, Plains, Mistlands) presents a new set of challenges, resources, and a boss that must be defeated to progress. The world is procedurally generated, meaning each playthrough is unique, and there are no quests or NPCs—just you, the environment, and the looming threat of the Forsaken.
Enshrouded’s progression is a mix of quests, skill points, and building. You wake up as a Flameborn, the last hope of a fallen civilization. You’ll discover ancient structures, rescue NPCs (like the Blacksmith and Alchemist) who then set up in your base and unlock new crafting recipes. The skill tree is extensive, allowing for different playstyles (e.g., ranger, mage, melee). The Shroud is a deadly purple mist that covers parts of the map; you can only stay inside it for a limited time before dying, and this timer can be extended by upgrading your Flame (the game’s central progression mechanic).
Building and Base Construction
Building is a core pillar in both games, but the systems are very different.
- Valheim uses a structural integrity system. You must place support beams and walls, and if a structure is too tall or spans too far without support, it will collapse. This adds a layer of engineering challenge. You can build with wood, stone, and later, iron and black marble. The building is piece-by-piece, similar to Rust or Minecraft, but with a Viking aesthetic.
- Enshrouded uses a voxel-based system, similar to games like LEGO Worlds or Dragon Quest Builders. You can place full blocks, which can be shaped and textured. There is no structural integrity, so you can build floating castles or massive towers without worrying about support. You can also terraform the ground, digging tunnels or creating mountains. The building freedom is arguably greater, but it lacks the satisfying physics of Valheim.
For solo players, Enshrouded’s building is more forgiving and allows for more creative expression. For co-op groups, Valheim’s structural challenges can be a fun puzzle, but Enshrouded’s ease of use might be more appealing for a relaxed building session.
Combat and Exploration
Combat in Valheim is methodical and weighty. You have a stamina bar that governs attacks, blocking, and dodging. There is a real risk of death, and enemies can be punishing, especially in the early game. The combat is melee-focused but also includes bows and a limited set of magic weapons later on. Parrying is a key skill, and timing is everything.
Combat in Enshrouded is faster and more fluid. You have a similar stamina system, but there are more movement options, including a double jump and a glider (which you get early on). Magic is a fully fleshed-out school, with wands, staves, and spells that can be aimed. The skill tree allows for more build variety, and the overall feel is more like a modern action RPG than a brutal survival sim.
Exploration in Valheim is driven by the need for new resources. You’ll sail across the ocean to find new biomes, and the sense of discovery is immense. The world is vast, but it can also feel empty at times, with large stretches of nothing.
Exploration in Enshrouded is more directed. There are points of interest, ancient structures, and lore notes scattered around. You’ll often find new crafting recipes or materials in these locations. The world is handcrafted, so it feels more cohesive and detailed, but it is also smaller than Valheim’s.
Common Problems and How to Choose
Both games have their share of issues, especially in Early Access.
- Valheim suffers from a lack of content in the later biomes (Mistlands was incomplete for a long time, and the Ashlands is still in development). The building system can be frustrating when things collapse, and the combat can feel clunky for some.
- Enshrouded has performance issues on lower-end PCs, and the game’s world, while beautiful, can feel repetitive in its layout (similar ruins, same enemy types). The Shroud mechanic can be annoying, as it forces you to rush through certain areas, and the timer can be a source of stress rather than fun.
To choose, consider these factors:
- If you want a pure survival challenge with a sense of dread and accomplishment, choose Valheim.
- If you want a more casual, story-driven experience with better building tools and smoother combat, choose Enshrouded.
- If you play solo, Valheim’s difficulty can be brutal at times, but it is manageable with careful preparation. Enshrouded is more forgiving, and the quests give you a clear direction.
- If you play co-op, both are great, but Valheim’s shared progression and the need to work together to survive can create stronger team bonds. Enshrouded’s building system is more fun to collaborate on.
Cost and Availability
Both games are available on Steam and are priced similarly (around $20-25). Valheim is also on Xbox Game Pass for console and PC. Enshrouded is currently PC-only (Steam), with console versions planned for later. Both are in Early Access, meaning you get the game at a lower price but with the understanding that it’s not finished. Prices can change, but the value proposition is similar: you get a lot of hours for your money.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which game is more fun to play solo?
Valheim offers a more intense and rewarding solo experience because the difficulty forces you to master every mechanic. Enshrouded is more accessible and less punishing, making it a better choice for solo players who prefer a relaxed pace or are new to survival games.
Can I play both with friends on different platforms?
Valheim supports cross-play between Steam and Xbox, but not with PlayStation. Enshrouded is PC-only for now, so no cross-play is available. Both allow up to 10 (Valheim) or 16 (Enshrouded) players in a single world, but the recommended number is 2-4 for the best experience.
Which game has better building?
Enshrouded has more creative freedom due to its voxel system and lack of structural limits. Valheim’s building is more grounded and requires planning, which some players find more satisfying. It’s a matter of preference.
Is Enshrouded a copy of Valheim?
No, but it’s heavily inspired by it. Enshrouded takes the survival-crafting formula and adds a stronger narrative, a skill tree, and more modern combat. It’s more like a blend of Valheim and Breath of the Wild.
Which game has more content right now?
Valheim has been in Early Access longer, so it has more biomes and bosses, but some are still incomplete. Enshrouded has a smaller but more polished world with quests and a clear progression path. Both are constantly updated, so this can change.
Are there any safety concerns with these games?
No, these are standard video games with no real-world safety issues. However, be mindful of your playtime, as both games are notoriously addictive and can lead to long sessions. Take breaks and stay hydrated.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- DNF vs DNF5: Which Package Manager?
- Car Trends Making Cars Worse: 7 Downsides
- Nostalgic Classic Games Revamped on G2A?
- Nvidia RTX 4000 Super GPUs: Full Specs & Buying Guide
- Photoshop vs Lightroom AI Features Compared
- Korean SUV Making BMW and Audi Owners Question Their Choices?