ExpressVPN and Surfshark are two of the most popular VPN services, but they serve different priorities: ExpressVPN is the premium choice with a proven track record and top-tier speeds, while Surfshark offers nearly identical core features at a lower price with unlimited simultaneous connections. If you want the absolute best performance and reliability and are willing to pay for it, choose ExpressVPN; if you want a budget-friendly option that still delivers strong security and speed, choose Surfshark.
Background: How These Two VPNs Compare
Both ExpressVPN and Surfshark are based in privacy-friendly jurisdictions (the British Virgin Islands and the Netherlands, respectively), which means neither is subject to mandatory data retention laws. Both use AES-256 encryption, support the OpenVPN and WireGuard protocols, and operate strict no-logs policies that have been independently audited. The key difference lies in their approach: ExpressVPN has been around since 2009 and focuses on a polished, premium experience, while Surfshark, launched in 2018, positions itself as a value-driven service with aggressive pricing and unlimited device support.
How They Work: Technology and Infrastructure
Both VPNs route your internet traffic through encrypted tunnels to remote servers, masking your IP address and making it appear as if you are browsing from the server’s location. ExpressVPN uses its proprietary Lightway protocol, which is designed to be fast and reliable, especially on unstable connections. Surfshark uses the WireGuard protocol (via its implementation called "WireGuard"), which is known for its speed and efficiency. Both services operate large server networks: ExpressVPN has servers in 105 countries, while Surfshark has servers in 100 countries. In practice, this means you can access geo-restricted content from virtually anywhere.
Performance and Speed: Real-World Differences
Speed is where ExpressVPN often edges out Surfshark, though the gap has narrowed. In independent speed tests, ExpressVPN consistently achieves higher download speeds, especially on long-distance connections, due to its optimized network and Lightway protocol. Surfshark is no slouch—its WireGuard implementation delivers fast speeds for most users—but it may occasionally drop to 70-80% of your base speed on distant servers. For streaming, both can unblock Netflix, Hulu, BBC iPlayer, and Disney+, but ExpressVPN has a slight edge in reliability because it actively works around VPN blocks more aggressively. If you are a gamer or stream in 4K, ExpressVPN’s lower latency and consistent throughput make it the safer bet.
Security and Privacy: Which Is More Trustworthy?
Both services offer military-grade encryption, kill switches, and DNS leak protection. ExpressVPN operates a "TrustedServer" technology that runs servers entirely on RAM, meaning no data is written to hard drives—a strong privacy feature. Surfshark also uses RAM-only servers and has passed independent audits of its no-logs policy. Surfshark goes a step further with a built-in ad blocker (CleanWeb) and a "Camouflage Mode" that disguises VPN traffic as normal internet traffic, which can be useful in restrictive countries. ExpressVPN’s privacy credentials are equally solid: it has been tested in real-world scenarios (e.g., a server seizure in Turkey) where investigators found no logs. For most users, both are equally trustworthy; the choice comes down to extra features versus brand reputation.
Cost and Value: What You Get for Your Money
Surfshark is significantly cheaper than ExpressVPN. A typical two-year plan from Surfshark costs around $2.30 per month, while ExpressVPN’s annual plan is about $8.32 per month. Surfshark also allows unlimited simultaneous connections, so you can protect every device in your household—phones, laptops, smart TVs, and even routers—with one subscription. ExpressVPN limits you to five concurrent connections, which is fine for most individuals but may be restrictive for large families. Both offer a 30-day money-back guarantee, so you can test them risk-free. The extra cost of ExpressVPN buys you a slightly faster network, a more polished app, and 24/7 live chat support that is consistently responsive.
Common Problems and How to Troubleshoot
The most common issue with both VPNs is slow speed or connection drops. If you experience this:
- Switch protocols: Try changing from WireGuard (Surfshark) or Lightway (ExpressVPN) to OpenVPN, which is often more stable on certain networks.
- Change servers: Connect to a server closer to your physical location to reduce latency.
- Check your base internet: Disconnect the VPN and run a speed test; if your base speed is low, the VPN isn’t the problem.
- Update the app: Outdated apps can cause compatibility issues with your operating system.
Another common issue is streaming sites blocking VPN traffic. If Netflix or Hulu detects the VPN, try a different server in the same country or contact support for a recommended server.
How to Choose Between ExpressVPN and Surfshark
To decide, ask yourself these questions:
- What is your budget? If you want to save money, Surfshark is the clear winner.
- How many devices do you need to protect? Surfshark’s unlimited connections beat ExpressVPN’s five-device limit.
- Do you prioritize raw speed? ExpressVPN is slightly faster, especially on long-distance connections.
- Do you need advanced features? Surfshark offers ad blocking, multi-hop (double VPN), and dedicated IP options at no extra cost.
- Do you travel to restrictive countries? Both work well, but Surfshark’s Camouflage Mode is a unique advantage.
If you are a power user who wants the best performance and doesn’t mind paying a premium, ExpressVPN is the industry standard. If you are a budget-conscious user who wants a full-featured VPN for all your devices, Surfshark offers unbeatable value.
Alternatives to Consider
If neither fits your needs, consider these alternatives:
- NordVPN: Similar price to ExpressVPN but with a larger server network and double encryption.
- ProtonVPN: Offers a free tier and strong privacy credentials, but speeds are slower on the free plan.
- Mullvad: Focuses on anonymity, accepting cash payments, but has a smaller server network.
- Private Internet Access: Budget-friendly with a large server fleet, but based in the US (a Five Eyes country).
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Surfshark as secure as ExpressVPN?
Yes, both use the same encryption standards and have passed independent audits. Surfshark’s RAM-only servers and no-logs policy are comparable to ExpressVPN’s TrustedServer technology. The main difference is that ExpressVPN has been around longer, giving it a longer track record of reliability.
Can I use ExpressVPN and Surfshark on my router?
Yes, both offer router apps or manual configuration guides. ExpressVPN has a dedicated router firmware, while Surfshark provides setup instructions for popular router models. Using a VPN on your router protects all devices connected to your home network.
Which VPN is better for streaming Netflix?
Both can unblock Netflix, but ExpressVPN tends to be more reliable because it actively works around VPN blocks. Surfshark also works, but you may need to try a few servers before finding one that isn’t blocked.
Does Surfshark keep logs?
Surfshark has a strict no-logs policy that has been independently audited. It does not track your browsing history, connection timestamps, or IP addresses. The only data it retains is your email address for account management.
Which VPN is faster: ExpressVPN or Surfshark?
ExpressVPN is generally faster, especially on long-distance connections, due to its Lightway protocol and optimized network. Surfshark’s WireGuard implementation is also fast, but it may be slightly slower on distant servers. For most everyday use, both are fast enough for streaming and browsing.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Arctic Sea Ice Forecasts Disagree: What to Do
- MySQL Workbench to VPS: SSH Tunnel Setup
- Bluesky Beginners Guide: How to Get Started5.00 min/km
- LG V20 Won’t Turn On? Fixed
- Snagit vs Camtasia: Which One Do You Need?
- Scale a Small Business Without Losing Culture