keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

FCC Fines Wireless Carriers for Sharing Location Data

Card No. 06·77069 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has fined major U.S. wireless carriers for selling or sharing customers’ real-time location data without proper consent. The fines, announced in 2020 and reaffirmed in 2024, target AT&T, Verizon, Sprint, and T-Mobile for violations of Section 222 of the Communications Act, which requires carriers to protect customer proprietary network information (CPNI). This article explains what happened, why it matters, and what you can do to protect your location privacy.

Background: How the Location Data Controversy Began

The issue came to light in 2018 when reports revealed that wireless carriers were selling access to customers’ real-time location data to third-party aggregators. These aggregators, in turn, sold the data to a wide range of businesses, including bounty hunters, tow truck operators, and even some local law enforcement agencies. The practice was not limited to a single carrier; all four major U.S. carriers were involved to varying degrees.

The FCC’s investigation found that carriers failed to take reasonable steps to protect this sensitive data. In some cases, a single employee at a third-party company could access a customer’s location without any meaningful oversight. The carriers argued that they had contracts requiring aggregators to obtain consent, but the FCC concluded that these contracts were not enforced and that the carriers did not adequately vet the companies they shared data with.

The FCC’s Enforcement Actions and Fines

In February 2020, the FCC proposed fines totaling nearly $208 million against the four carriers. The final amounts, announced in April 2024, were:

  • AT&T: $57 million
  • Verizon: $46.9 million
  • T-Mobile: $80 million (including Sprint, which T-Mobile acquired in 2020)
  • Sprint: $12.2 million (before the merger)

These fines were the result of a lengthy investigation that began in 2019. The FCC’s order stated that the carriers had violated Section 222 by disclosing CPNI without customer consent. The carriers were also required to implement compliance plans to prevent future violations.

How the Location Data Sharing Worked

Wireless carriers track your device’s location through cell tower triangulation, GPS, and Wi-Fi positioning. This data is essential for providing service, but it is also commercially valuable. Carriers sold access to this data through “location aggregator” services. Here is how the chain typically worked:

  1. A third-party company (the aggregator) signed a contract with a carrier to access location data for legitimate purposes, such as roadside assistance or fraud prevention.
  2. The aggregator then sold access to its platform to other companies, often with little oversight.
  3. Employees of those downstream companies could query the system with a phone number and receive the device’s location.
  4. In some documented cases, a single employee at a small tow truck company could locate any customer of any major carrier.

The carriers argued that they had “audited” the aggregators, but the FCC found these audits were inadequate and often based on self-reporting.

Why This Matters for Your Privacy

Your location is among the most sensitive data your phone generates. It can reveal where you live, work, worship, seek medical care, and who you meet. Unlike browsing history or app usage, location data is often collected in real time and can be used for physical surveillance. The FCC’s action is significant because it establishes that carriers have a legal obligation to protect this data, not just a business incentive.

It also highlights a broader problem: even if you never gave consent, your data may have been shared. The FCC’s order found that carriers did not obtain consent from customers before sharing location data with these aggregators. In many cases, customers were not even aware that such sharing was possible.

What You Can Do to Protect Your Location Data

While you cannot undo past data sharing, you can take steps to limit future exposure:

  • Turn off location services for apps that do not need it. On iPhone: Settings > Privacy & Security > Location Services. On Android: Settings > Location > App permissions.
  • Disable “precise location” for apps that only need a general area (e.g., weather apps).
  • Check your carrier’s privacy settings. Some carriers allow you to opt out of data sharing for marketing purposes, though this may not cover all uses.
  • Use a VPN to hide your IP address, but note that a VPN does not hide your cell tower location from your carrier.
  • Consider a privacy-focused wireless plan that does not sell location data, though these are rare and may not be available in all areas.

Common Misconceptions

One common misconception is that the FCC fines mean the practice has stopped. In reality, the fines were issued for past violations, and the carriers have since changed their policies. However, the FCC’s order requires ongoing compliance reporting, and future violations could bring additional penalties.

Another misconception is that only people who opted in were affected. The FCC found that the carriers did not obtain consent at all for many of these disclosures. Even if you never agreed to share your location, your data may have been part of these data feeds.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Am I entitled to a refund or compensation from these fines?
No. The fines are paid to the U.S. Treasury, not to consumers. However, you may have a private right of action under state law, but that is separate from the FCC’s action.

Q: How do I know if my location was shared?
You cannot know for certain. The FCC’s order does not provide individual notification. However, if you were a customer of any of the four major carriers between 2015 and 2019, your data may have been exposed.

Q: Can law enforcement still get my location without a warrant?
Yes, in some cases. Carriers can disclose location data to law enforcement in emergencies or with a court order. The FCC’s order does not change those rules.

Q: Does turning off location services stop my carrier from tracking me?
No. Your carrier can still determine your location via cell tower triangulation even with location services off. That is how 911 calls are routed.

Q: Are smaller carriers affected?
The FCC’s order targeted the four largest carriers. Smaller carriers may have similar practices, but they were not part of this enforcement action.

Q: Can I sue my carrier for sharing my location?
Some state laws allow consumers to sue for privacy violations. The FCC’s order does not prevent that, but you should consult a lawyer to understand your options.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →