The UK’s antitrust regulator is examining Google’s advertising technology (ad tech) practices, focusing on whether the company unfairly uses data from its ad-buying tools to advantage its own services. The probe, led by the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), asks a core question: does Google’s access to data from advertisers and publishers give it an illegal monopoly in the digital ad market? This article explains what the probe covers, how ad data flows through Google’s systems, and what the potential outcomes could mean for businesses and users.
Background: Why the UK is Investigating Google’s Ad Tech
In May 2022, the CMA opened a formal investigation into Google’s ad tech stack under Chapter II of the Competition Act 1998. The investigation was prompted by concerns raised in the CMA’s earlier market study into online platforms and digital advertising (published in 2020), which found that Google held significant market power in several parts of the ad tech chain. The UK is not alone – the European Commission opened a similar probe in 2021, and the US Department of Justice filed an antitrust lawsuit in 2023. However, the UK case is notable because it focuses specifically on how Google’s data advantage might distort competition.
The CMA is examining three core areas: (1) whether Google’s ad-buying tools (like DV360) are given preferential access to data from its ad-selling tools (like Ad Manager), (2) whether Google’s ownership of the largest ad exchange (AdX) creates a conflict of interest, and (3) whether Google’s practices make it harder for rival ad tech companies to compete. The probe is ongoing, with the CMA expected to issue a decision in 2025 or later.
How Google’s Ad Data Works: The Double-Sided Market
To understand the probe, you need to know how the ad tech chain works. When a website wants to display ads, it uses a supply-side platform (SSP) to sell ad space. Advertisers use a demand-side platform (DSP) to buy that space. In between sits an ad exchange, which matches buyers and sellers in real-time auctions.
Google operates at all three levels:
- SSP: Google Ad Manager (which includes the legacy DoubleClick for Publishers) is used by many large publishers to manage their ad inventory.
- Ad Exchange: AdX is one of the largest ad exchanges, processing billions of bids per day.
- DSP: Display & Video 360 (DV360) and Google Ads are used by advertisers to buy ad space programmatically.
The CMA’s concern is that Google can see the bids coming into AdX from rival DSPs (like The Trade Desk or Amazon’s DSP) and then use that information to adjust its own bids in DV360. In a traditional auction, bidders don’t know each other’s prices, but Google – as the exchange operator – has access to that data. The CMA argues this creates an unfair advantage, potentially leading to higher prices for advertisers and lower revenue for publishers.
The Core Question: Is Google’s Data Advantage Anti-Competitive?
The probe focuses on a specific practice known as “bid shading” and the use of “last look” in auctions. Bid shading is a technique where a DSP lowers its bid slightly to pay less than its true valuation. Google has argued that this is a legitimate way to save money for advertisers. But the CMA is investigating whether Google uses its exchange data to shade bids more aggressively than rivals, effectively squeezing out competition.
Another issue is “data sharing” between Google’s ad products. For example, when a publisher uses Ad Manager, Google collects data on user behavior. That data is then potentially used to target ads on Google’s own properties (like YouTube or Search) or in DV360 campaigns. Rivals do not have access to this data, which the CMA says may create a self-reinforcing loop: more data leads to better ad targeting, which attracts more advertisers, which generates more data.
Google has publicly denied these allegations, stating that its ad tech tools operate independently and that advertisers and publishers have many alternatives. However, in 2023, Google made a pre-emptive move by offering to allow rival ad exchanges to use its Ad Manager infrastructure, but the CMA rejected this as insufficient.
What the Probe Could Mean for You (Advertisers, Publishers, Users)
If the CMA finds against Google, it could impose behavioral remedies (like requiring Google to share data with rivals) or structural remedies (like forcing Google to sell off parts of its ad tech business). The latter is considered a radical option, but it has been suggested by the CMA in a 2023 working paper.
For advertisers, a remedy could mean lower ad prices and more transparency in how their budgets are spent. For publishers, it could mean higher revenue per ad impression, as they might receive fairer bids. For users, the impact is less direct, but could result in less targeted ads (if data sharing is restricted) or better privacy protections.
The probe also has implications for the UK’s post-Brexit regulatory stance. The CMA has become more assertive in tech regulation, and a decision against Google could set a precedent for other cases, such as its ongoing investigation into mobile ecosystems.
How to Stay Informed and Prepare
If you run a business that relies on digital advertising, here are practical steps to stay ahead:
- Monitor the CMA’s case page (competition case 50972) for updates.
- Diversify your ad tech stack – don’t rely solely on Google tools. Test alternative SSPs and DSPs.
- Review your data collection practices to ensure you are not inadvertently giving Google more data than necessary.
- Consult legal counsel if you receive any requests for information from the CMA.
For publishers, consider using header bidding to bypass Google’s exchange. Header bidding allows multiple exchanges to bid on your inventory simultaneously, which can increase revenue and reduce Google’s market power.
Common Misconceptions About the Probe
One misconception is that the probe is about Google’s search dominance. It is not – it is specifically about ad tech, which is a separate market. Another misconception is that the probe will result in immediate fines. The CMA can fine companies up to 10% of global turnover, but in this case, the focus is on changing behavior, not just punishment.
Some also believe that the probe will lead to a breakup of Google. While that is a possibility, it is not the most likely outcome. The more probable scenario is a set of behavioral remedies, such as mandating that Google provides rival ad tech companies with equal access to its data or requiring it to separate its exchange and DSP operations.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What does the UK antitrust probe into Google’s ad data actually accuse Google of?
A: The CMA alleges that Google abused its dominant position in ad tech by using data from its ad exchange to give its own ad-buying tools an unfair advantage, potentially raising costs for advertisers and reducing revenue for publishers.
Q: How long will the investigation take?
A: The CMA’s investigation began in May 2022 and was initially expected to conclude within 18 months. However, due to the complexity and the volume of evidence, it is now expected to continue into 2025 or later.
Q: What is “ad tech” and why is it important?
A: Ad tech is the software and tools used to buy and sell digital advertising. It is a multi-billion pound market in the UK, and Google’s dominance in it has been a long-standing concern for regulators.
Q: How does Google’s data advantage affect me as a consumer?
A: If Google’s practices lead to higher ad prices, those costs are often passed on to consumers through higher product prices. Additionally, the data advantage may result in more invasive tracking, as Google can build more detailed profiles on users.
Q: What happens if Google is found guilty?
A: The CMA can order Google to change its practices, impose fines, or even require it to sell parts of its ad tech business. Google could also appeal any decision to the Competition Appeal Tribunal.
Q: Are there any similar probes in other countries?
A: Yes, the European Commission has a similar investigation, and the US Department of Justice has filed a lawsuit against Google’s ad tech practices. The outcomes in the UK could influence these other cases.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Unbox ASMR Codes: What They Are & How to Use5.00 min/km
- Repurposed Old Motorola Phone for Homelab?
- How to Evaluate AI Vendors for Data Security, Privacy & Compliance
- Best Ergonomic Mouse: Top Picks & Buying Guide
- Captions in Google Slides: How to Add & Format Them
- Use Mac Type in Japanese? Full Guide