keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Game Challenge or Bad Tutorial? How to Tell

Card No. 06·83079 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

This guide helps you figure out whether a game is genuinely challenging or just failing to explain itself. You’ll learn to spot the signs of each, test your assumptions, and decide whether to keep pushing, change tactics, or look for help. No special tools are needed—just a bit of patience and a willingness to experiment.

What You’ll Need

  • The game in question (installed and running)
  • A way to take notes (phone, paper, or a text file)
  • Optional: access to a web browser for looking up official patch notes or community discussions

Step-by-Step

  1. Pause and identify what you’re stuck on. Is it a boss fight, a puzzle, a platforming section, or just understanding the controls? Write down the exact point where you feel lost or overwhelmed.
  2. Check if the game taught you the needed mechanic. Look through the tutorial messages, codex entries, or control menu. Did the game explicitly mention the ability or rule you’re struggling with? If it did, you might have missed it—go back and re-read.
  3. Try the obvious solution first. Often the intended path is simpler than you think: hit the glowing weak point, use the item you just picked up, or talk to the NPC you just met. If the obvious thing works, the game was probably fair.
  4. Experiment with different approaches. If the obvious fails, try something completely different. Change your loadout, use a different ability, or approach from another angle. A well-designed challenge usually has multiple viable strategies, even if one is easier.
  5. Look for patterns. Hard but fair games telegraph what’s coming: a boss winds up before a big attack, a puzzle has a consistent logic, or enemies follow a predictable patrol route. Can you find a pattern? If yes, it’s likely a challenge of execution or observation.
  6. Check if the game gives feedback. When you fail, does the game tell you why? A good game shows you what killed you, hints at a better approach, or at least lets you learn from your mistake. If you’re dying with no clue why, that’s a sign of poor explanation.
  7. Compare with your own skill level. Are you new to this genre? A game that’s easy for veterans might be unfairly hard for you. That’s not necessarily the game’s fault—but if the game doesn’t offer difficulty options or a way to practice, it’s still a design flaw.
  8. Search for clues in the game world. Often the game gives you hints through environmental storytelling, item descriptions, or NPC dialogue. Read everything you can find. If the answer is hidden in a lore note you skipped, that’s on you—but if it’s in a place you couldn’t have reached yet, that’s bad design.
  9. Look up a guide or walkthrough (sparingly). If you’re truly stuck, a quick search can reveal the intended solution. If the guide says “just do X” and you feel stupid for not seeing it, you might have missed a tutorial. If the guide says “you need to grind for 10 hours,” that’s probably artificial difficulty.
  10. Ask yourself: is the game respecting my time? A challenging game should make you want to improve. If you’re just repeating the same 5-minute section for the 20th time with no progress, that’s padding, not challenge.

Common Mistakes

  • Assuming the game is out to get you. Sometimes you’re just tired, distracted, or not in the right mindset. Take a break and come back fresh.
  • Ignoring the tutorial because you’ve played similar games. Even veterans need to learn the specific quirks of a new game. Read the tooltips.
  • Refusing to use items or abilities because you’re saving them. If a boss is hard, use your best consumables. You’ll find more.
  • Confusing “hard” with “unfair.” A boss that one-shots you but has a clear tell is fair. A boss that one-shots you with no warning and no counterplay is unfair.

Tips

  • Turn on subtitles and tutorial hints. Many games have options to make tutorials more explicit or to repeat tips.
  • Watch a video of someone else playing the same section. This can reveal a mechanic you missed or show you a clever strategy.
  • Use the game’s own practice tools. Many games have training modes, boss rush modes, or the ability to replay levels. Use them to learn patterns without the pressure of progress.
  • Check the game’s patch notes. Sometimes a section is hard because of a bug or balance issue that the developers have fixed. If you’re on an old version, update.
  • Talk to other players. Online communities can give you advice or just confirm that the section is hard for everyone, which is reassuring.

Troubleshooting

If you’ve tried everything and still can’t tell: Take a step back and ask if you’re having fun. If the frustration outweighs the satisfaction, it doesn’t matter whether it’s fair or not—it’s not working for you. Set the game down and come back later, or move on. There’s no shame in dropping a game that isn’t clicking.

If the difficulty spike feels like a bug: Check the game’s official forums or subreddit. If others are complaining about the same spot, it’s likely a design issue. If you’re the only one, you might be missing something obvious—ask for help specifically.

If you’re stuck on a puzzle and the game won’t give hints: Try looking at it from a different angle (literally). Sometimes puzzles are solved by rotating the camera, using an item you forgot you had, or interacting with something you assumed was just decoration.

If you’re stuck on a boss and feel underleveled: Check if you can leave and come back later. If you can’t, you might be in a “skill check” area—the game expects you to have mastered certain mechanics. Practice those mechanics in earlier areas.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How do I know if a game is poorly explained or I’m just bad?

A: If the game gives you clear feedback and you can learn from your mistakes, it’s probably fair. If you’re dying without any idea why, or the game never teaches you the required mechanic, it’s likely poor explanation.

Q: Should I lower the difficulty if I’m stuck?

A: Yes, if the option exists. There’s no shame in playing on easy. The point is to enjoy yourself. If the game doesn’t have difficulty options, consider using mods or cheats (if allowed) to get past a frustrating section.

Q: What if the game is hard because of bad controls or UI?

A: That’s a form of poor explanation. If the controls are clunky, check if you can remap them. If the UI is confusing, look for settings to simplify it. If the game is genuinely unplayable due to controls, it’s not your fault.

Q: Is it okay to look up a guide?

A: Absolutely. Guides exist to help. Looking up a hint is not cheating—it’s using available resources. Just try to solve it yourself first, so you don’t spoil the fun.

Q: How do I know if a game is artificially difficult?

A: Artificial difficulty usually means inflated numbers (enemies have huge health pools, you do little damage) or unfair mechanics (random instant-death traps, no checkpoints). If the game expects you to grind or use a specific build to progress, that’s often artificial.

Q: Can a game be both challenging and poorly explained?

A: Yes. Some games are hard because they don’t explain themselves well. For example, a game that requires you to use a mechanic that was only mentioned once in a tooltip is both challenging and poorly explained. In that case, it’s a design flaw.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →