keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Metroidvania vs Search Action: Genre Guide

Card No. 06·83567 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Metroidvania and search action are two names for the same classic genre of side-scrolling adventure games where you explore a large, interconnected map, unlock new abilities, and use those abilities to reach previously inaccessible areas. The key difference is regional: “search action” is the term popularized in Japan, while “Metroidvania” is the Western portmanteau of Metroid and Castlevania. This article explains the genre’s history, core mechanics, how to choose your first game, and common pitfalls to avoid.

What Defines a Metroidvania / Search Action Game

At its core, the genre has three pillars that almost every title shares:

  • Interconnected map: The world is a single large area (or a few connected zones) with shortcuts, loops, and locked doors. You rarely see a level-select screen; instead, you walk from one region to another.
  • Ability-gated progression: You cannot access certain areas until you obtain a specific tool—a double jump, a dash, a wall climb, or a key item. This creates a natural “backtracking” loop where you revisit old areas with new powers.
  • Non-linear exploration: Within a given ability set, you can choose the order of objectives. You might fight bosses in different sequences, or find optional upgrades that make the game easier.

Not every game with a large map qualifies. A linear platformer like Super Mario Bros. has levels, but no ability-gated backtracking. A pure action game like Devil May Cry has combat but lacks the interconnected world. The combination of all three is what makes a Metroidvania.

History: Why Two Names for One Genre

The genre’s roots go back to 1986 with Metroid on the NES, which introduced a large, non-linear world where you collected missiles and energy tanks to progress. The same year, Castlevania was a linear level-based game, but its 1997 sequel Castlevania: Symphony of the Night adopted the Metroid formula—an interconnected castle, RPG-style leveling, and new abilities that unlocked areas. Western fans coined the portmanteau “Metroidvania” to describe this hybrid.

In Japan, the genre is more commonly called search action (探索アクション, tansaku akushon). This term predates the Western portmanteau and reflects a different emphasis: the Japanese name highlights the act of searching and exploring, while the Western name references two specific franchises. The distinction is purely linguistic—both terms describe the same design philosophy.

How the Genre Works: A Typical Play Loop

Most Metroidvanias follow a predictable rhythm that players find satisfying:

  1. You start in a small, safe area with basic movement (run, jump, attack).
  2. You explore outward, encountering enemies and dead ends that hint at future abilities.
  3. You find a boss or a puzzle that rewards you with a new ability (e.g., double jump, dash, or a weapon that breaks walls).
  4. You backtrack to earlier areas, now using the new ability to reach previously blocked paths.
  5. You repeat steps 2–4, gradually filling in the map and uncovering the full picture.

Modern entries add quality-of-life features like fast travel, waypoint markers, and map notes to reduce frustration. Some games, like Hollow Knight, are known for their difficulty and sparse guidance, while others, like Ori and the Blind Forest, offer a more guided experience with a clear story.

How to Choose Your First Game

With hundreds of titles across PC, consoles, and mobile, picking a starting point can be overwhelming. Consider these factors:

  • Difficulty: Hollow Knight and Blasphemous are punishing. Guacamelee! and Yoku’s Island Express are more forgiving.
  • Pacing: Some games are combat-heavy (Dead Cells—though that is a roguelite, not a pure Metroidvania), others focus on puzzles (La-Mulana), and others on atmosphere (Ori).
  • Map size: Super Metroid takes about 8–10 hours; Hollow Knight can take 40+ hours to fully complete.
  • Game feel: Try a demo or watch a few minutes of gameplay. The genre lives or dies on how satisfying movement and combat feel.

A common recommendation for newcomers is Guacamelee! (lighter combat, clear goals) or Ori and the Blind Forest (beautiful, forgiving, with a gentle learning curve). Veterans often point to Super Metroid as the genre’s gold standard.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

New players frequently hit the same walls:

  • Getting lost: The map is big and often lacks clear direction. Solution: use the in-game map, mark unexplored doors, and talk to NPCs for hints.
  • Backtracking fatigue: Re-walking long corridors is tedious. Solution: unlock fast travel as soon as it appears, and plan routes to pick up multiple items in one trip.
  • Misunderstanding ability gating: Some players think a locked door is a bug. It is not—you need a specific ability, and the game usually telegraphs this with visual clues (colored switches, cracked walls, high ledges).
  • “It’s just a platformer”: A common misconception is that Metroidvanias are only about jumping. In reality, exploration and ability progression are equally important. Combat and puzzle-solving often take center stage.

Another misconception: every game with a large map is a Metroidvania. Dark Souls has a connected world and shortcuts, but it lacks ability-gated progression (you can walk anywhere from the start if you are skilled). The Legend of Zelda is a top-down adventure, not a side-scroller, so it is usually classified separately, though it shares the same exploration DNA.

Comparisons: Metroidvania vs. Roguelike vs. Open World

It helps to distinguish Metroidvanias from adjacent genres:

  • Roguelike: Roguelikes (Hades, Dead Cells) feature permadeath and procedurally generated levels. Metroidvanias have a fixed map and no permadeath (though some, like Rogue Legacy, blend both).
  • Open world: Open-world games (Breath of the Wild, Elden Ring) are 3D, vast, and often let you go anywhere from the start. Metroidvanias are typically 2D and lock progression behind abilities, not just raw difficulty.
  • Linear platformer: Games like Celeste or Super Meat Boy are pure platformers with no ability-gated backtracking. They are about execution, not exploration.

A hybrid genre, the “Metroidvania-like” (e.g., Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night), is a direct spiritual successor to Castlevania and sticks closely to the formula. Others, like Environmental Station Alpha, push the genre’s boundaries with cryptic puzzles.

Costs and Where to Play

Metroidvanias range from free indie titles to full-priced AAA releases. Many are available on PC (Steam, GOG), Nintendo Switch, PlayStation, Xbox, and mobile. Prices vary widely: older classics like Super Metroid are available via Nintendo Switch Online, while newer indies typically cost $15–$30. The genre is known for its strong indie presence—many celebrated entries come from small studios with modest budgets.

There is no standard “cost” beyond the purchase price. Some games offer free demos, and many are included in subscription services like Xbox Game Pass or PlayStation Plus. Always check the platform’s store page for current pricing and system requirements.

Safety and Accuracy Notes

This genre involves no real-world safety risks. The formula is a rough estimate, not a precise tool. For a full completionist run, expect to spend 20–50% more time than the main story.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Metroidvania the same as search action?

Yes, they are two names for the same genre. “Search action” is the Japanese term, while “Metroidvania” is the Western portmanteau. Both describe games with interconnected maps, ability-gated progression, and non-linear exploration.

What is the best Metroidvania for beginners?

Most players recommend Guacamelee! or Ori and the Blind Forest for their forgiving difficulty, clear guidance, and polished controls. Super Metroid is also a good starting point if you are comfortable with older graphics and minimal hand-holding.

Why do Metroidvanias require backtracking?

Backtracking is the core mechanic. When you gain a new ability, you revisit old areas to access previously blocked paths, find upgrades, and uncover secrets. This creates a sense of mastery and rewards exploration.

Can a Metroidvania be 3D?

Yes, though it is rare. Games like Metroid Prime and Dark Souls (if you consider it one) apply the formula in 3D. However, the genre is traditionally associated with 2D side-scrolling.

How long does a typical Metroidvania take to beat?

Main story runs typically take 8–15 hours, while 100% completion can take 20–40 hours. The length varies widely—some indie titles are under 5 hours, while massive ones like Hollow Knight can exceed 50 hours.

Are Metroidvanias still being made?

Yes, the genre is thriving. Recent releases like Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown (2024) and Blasphemous 2 (2023) show that both indie and AAA studios continue to innovate within the formula.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →