Rights issues and public issues are two distinct ways Indian companies raise capital from shareholders, and the key difference lies in who can buy: a rights issue is offered only to existing shareholders in proportion to their holdings, while a public issue is open to the general public. For existing shareholders, the most important thing to know is that a rights issue gives you a preferential right to buy new shares at a discount, but you are not obligated to do so—you can accept, decline, or even sell your rights. This article explains the mechanics, costs, risks, and strategic considerations so you can decide what to do when your company announces one.
What Is a Rights Issue?
A rights issue is a method of raising additional capital by offering new shares to existing shareholders. The company gives you the “right” to buy a certain number of new shares at a fixed price, usually lower than the market price. This right is proportionate to your current holding—if you own 1% of the company, you can buy 1% of the new shares. The offer is made through a letter of offer, and you typically have 15-30 days to decide.
Why do companies do this? Often to fund expansion, repay debt, or strengthen the balance sheet. For example, in 2020, many Indian banks used rights issues to raise capital to meet regulatory requirements. The key point is that a rights issue is a way to raise money without diluting existing shareholders’ percentage ownership—provided they participate fully.
What Is a Public Issue?
A public issue, also known as an initial public offering (IPO) when a company first lists, or a follow-on public offer (FPO) when already listed, is an offer of shares to the general public. Anyone—retail investors, institutional investors, high-net-worth individuals—can apply. Existing shareholders have no special rights; they can apply like everyone else, but they are not given any preferential allotment.
Public issues are used to raise capital from a wider investor base, increase liquidity, or allow early investors to exit. The price is determined through a book-building process or a fixed price, and allotment is often subject to oversubscription, meaning you may not get the full number of shares you applied for.
Key Differences: Rights vs Public Issue
Here’s a quick comparison to clarify the main points:
- Eligibility: Rights issue is only for existing shareholders; public issue is for everyone.
- Pricing: Rights issues are typically at a discount to the market price; public issues are priced at or near market value.
- Dilution: In a rights issue, your percentage ownership stays the same if you subscribe; in a public issue, your stake is diluted if you don’t buy more shares.
- Allotment: In a rights issue, you are guaranteed the shares you are entitled to; in a public issue, allotment is not guaranteed due to oversubscription.
- Cost: Rights issues have lower transaction costs because they don’t require extensive marketing; public issues involve underwriting, advertising, and listing fees.
- Timeline: Rights issues are usually faster, taking a few weeks; public issues can take months due to regulatory approvals and marketing.
Should You Subscribe to a Rights Issue?
Deciding whether to subscribe depends on your view of the company and the discount offered. Here are factors to consider:
- Financial health: Why is the company raising money? If it’s for growth, that’s positive. If it’s to cover losses, be cautious.
- Discount size: A larger discount increases the potential immediate gain, but the price may fall after the issue.
- Your cash position: Can you afford to invest more? If not, you can sell your rights in the market (if the rights are tradable) to get some value.
- Dilution impact: If you don’t subscribe, your ownership percentage drops. This may matter if you want to maintain control.
For example, if the rights issue is at a 20% discount and the company is fundamentally strong, subscribing might be a good deal. But if the stock is falling and the discount is small, it might be better to sell your rights or let them lapse.
Common Mistakes and Misconceptions
One common mistake is thinking that a rights issue is a free bonus. It’s not—you have to pay for the new shares. Another is assuming the market price will stay the same. In reality, the price usually drops to the TERP on the ex-date, so the discount doesn’t mean instant profit. For instance, if the CMP is ₹500 and the subscription price is ₹400, the price may fall to ₹480, so your gain is only the difference between ₹480 and ₹400, not between ₹500 and ₹400.
Another misconception is that you must subscribe to avoid losing money. If you don’t subscribe, you don’t lose money directly, but your stake is diluted. However, if you sell your rights, you can offset that dilution with cash. Also, note that rights issues are not taxable at the time of subscription, but capital gains tax applies when you sell the shares later.
Costs and Regulatory Aspects
For the company, a rights issue is cheaper than a public issue because it avoids underwriting commissions and large marketing expenses. For you as an investor, there is no fee to subscribe to a rights issue, but you may incur brokerage if you sell the rights or the shares later. The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) regulates both types of issues. For rights issues, the company must file a letter of offer with SEBI and stock exchanges. For public issues, the company must file a draft red herring prospectus (DRHP) for approval.
One important detail: rights entitlements are often tradable on the stock exchange. You can sell your rights if you don’t want to subscribe, but you must do so before the issue closes. The rights trading period is usually a few days to a week.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What happens if I don’t subscribe to a rights issue?
Your existing shares remain, but your percentage ownership in the company decreases because new shares are issued to others. You can sell your rights to get some compensation, but if you let them lapse, you get nothing.
Q: Can I apply for more shares than my entitlement in a rights issue?
Yes, you can apply for additional shares through the “renunciation” or “oversubscription” option. If other shareholders don’t take their full entitlement, you may get extra shares, but it’s not guaranteed.
Q: How is the rights issue price decided?
The company’s board decides the price, usually at a discount to the current market price. SEBI does not mandate a specific discount, but the price must be fair and not discriminatory.
Q: Is a rights issue a good investment?
It depends on the company’s prospects and the discount. If you believe in the company’s long-term growth, subscribing at a discount can be beneficial. If the company is struggling, even a discount may not be enough.
Q: What is the difference between a rights issue and a bonus issue?
A rights issue requires you to pay for new shares. A bonus issue gives you additional shares free of cost, but the share price adjusts proportionally, so the total value remains the same.
Q: How long do I have to decide on a rights issue?
The issue is open for a minimum of 15 days and a maximum of 30 days from the date of opening. You’ll receive a letter of offer with the exact dates.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Car Trends Making Cars Worse: 7 Downsides
- Nostalgic Classic Games Revamped on G2A?
- Nvidia RTX 4000 Super GPUs: Full Specs & Buying Guide
- Photoshop vs Lightroom AI Features Compared
- DNF vs DNF5: Which Package Manager?
- Korean SUV Making BMW and Audi Owners Question Their Choices?