keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Smartsheet vs Asana: Workflows and Controls

Card No. 06·82582 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Smartsheet and Asana both let teams build automated workflows, but they control them very differently: Smartsheet is a spreadsheet-style grid where workflow rules, permissions, and formulas act on rows and columns, while Asana is a task-and-project hierarchy where workflow rules, permissions, and forms act on tasks, sections, and projects. The choice between them usually comes down to whether your team thinks in rows (Smartsheet) or in lists and boards (Asana). This article compares how each tool structures workflows, what controls you get over automation and permissions, and which one fits common use cases.

Background: Where Each Tool Came From

Smartsheet launched in 2005 as a project-management layer on top of a familiar spreadsheet interface. Its core unit is a grid of rows and columns, where each row is typically one task, one asset, or one request, and columns hold dates, owners, statuses, and custom fields. Because it looks like Excel, it attracted operations teams, IT departments, and construction or event planners who already worked in spreadsheets.

Asana launched in 2008, founded by Dustin Moskovitz and Justin Rosenstein, and was designed from the start around tasks, projects, and teams. Its core unit is a task that lives inside a project, and that project can be viewed as a list, a Kanban board, a calendar, or a timeline (Gantt-style). Asana grew popular with marketing, product, and software teams that wanted a cleaner alternative to email and spreadsheets.

Both have matured into full work-management platforms with automation, forms, dashboards, and reporting. The fundamental difference remains: Smartsheet is row-centric, Asana is task-centric. That difference shapes every workflow and control feature below.

Workflow Structure: Rows vs Tasks

In Smartsheet, a workflow is a set of rules that trigger on a row when a condition is met. For example, you can set a rule: when the Status column changes to “Complete,” send an email to the row owner, lock the row, and update a date column. You build these rules in a separate Automation menu, and they apply to the whole sheet or to specific rows via a filter. You can also create a workflow that runs on a schedule, like every Monday at 9 AM, to send a summary of rows due this week.

In Asana, a workflow is a set of rules that trigger on a task when an event happens. For example: when a task is moved to the “In Progress” section, assign it to a specific person, set a due date, and add a comment. Rules live inside a project, and you can also create project-level templates that pre-build the workflow. Asana also has forms that feed new tasks into a project, and each form submission can trigger a rule.

Concrete example: a content calendar. In Smartsheet, you would have one row per article, with columns for title, author, status, due date, and publish date. A workflow could send a reminder 3 days before the due date if status is not “Published.” In Asana, you would have one task per article inside a “Content Calendar” project, with sections like “Draft,” “Review,” “Approved,” “Published.” A rule could move the task to “Review” when the draft attachment is added, and assign the reviewer.

Automation and Rules Compared

Both tools offer trigger-and-action automation, but the granularity differs.

  • Smartsheet triggers: when a row is added, changed, deleted, or when a specific column value changes. You can also trigger on a date (e.g., 5 days before a date column) or on a recurring schedule. Actions include sending email, updating a cell, locking/unlocking a row, moving a row to another sheet, and creating a row in another sheet.
  • Asana triggers: when a task is created, completed, assigned, or moved to a section. You can also trigger on a due date (e.g., 1 day before) or on a form submission. Actions include assigning a task, setting a due date, adding a tag, adding a comment, creating a subtask, and moving the task to a section.

Smartsheet allows cross-sheet automation: a row can be moved or copied to another sheet when a condition is met, which is powerful for handoffs between departments. Asana does not have a direct cross-project move in rules, but you can create a task in another project via a rule. Smartsheet also supports conditional logic with “if/then” branches in its premium automation packages, while Asana’s rules are simpler and more linear.

One major difference: Smartsheet automation can update any cell in a row, including custom formula columns, while Asana rules only affect task fields like assignee, due date, and section. If you need to calculate a value (e.g., budget variance) and then trigger an alert based on that number, Smartsheet is more flexible.

Control and Permissions

Permissions control who can see, edit, and run workflows. Smartsheet uses a sheet-level sharing model. You can share a sheet with individuals or groups and set their access level: Viewer, Editor, Editor with sharing, or Admin. You can also lock individual columns or rows so that only certain people can edit them. For example, you can lock the “Approved” column so only a manager can change it, while everyone else edits other columns. Smartsheet also has row-level permissions (in paid plans) that let you restrict which rows a user can see or edit within a shared sheet.

Asana uses a project-level and organization-level permission model. Each project has a privacy setting (public to the organization, private to members, or comment-only). Within a project, you can set a member’s role: commenter, editor, or admin. Asana does not have column-level or row-level permissions; every member of a project can see all tasks in that project (unless you use the premium “private tasks” feature, which hides a task from non-assignees).

For workflow controls specifically, Smartsheet lets you restrict who can create or edit automation rules at the sheet level. Asana lets you restrict who can create rules at the project level, and you can also disable rules for guests. Asana’s admin console gives organization-wide controls over who can create projects, use forms, or access certain features.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

A common misconception is that Smartsheet is “just a spreadsheet” and Asana is “just a to-do list.” In practice, Smartsheet has robust project views (Gantt, calendar, card) and Asana has custom fields and forms that mimic spreadsheet-like data. The real issue is the mental model.

Common problems with Smartsheet workflows:

  • Users forget to enable “Update” triggers on specific columns, so automation fires on any edit, causing noise.
  • Cross-sheet references (using formulas that pull data from another sheet) can break if the source sheet is renamed or moved.
  • Row-level permissions are complex to set up and can confuse users who see a sheet but not all rows.

Common problems with Asana workflows:

  • Rules only fire on tasks, not on subtasks, unless you specifically create a rule for subtasks.
  • Moving a task between projects can break rules that were tied to the original project’s sections.
  • Users often create too many rules, leading to duplicate notifications or tasks being reassigned unexpectedly.

Another misconception: you can’t do complex calculations in Asana. Asana has custom fields (numbers, text, dates) and you can add a “Formula” field in premium plans, but it’s limited to simple arithmetic on numeric fields. Smartsheet supports full spreadsheet formulas (SUMIF, VLOOKUP, etc.) and cross-sheet references, so it is far more powerful for data-heavy workflows.

How to Choose: Which One Fits Your Workflow

Choose Smartsheet if:

  • Your team already works in spreadsheets and needs to keep that structure.
  • You need complex formulas, cross-sheet references, or row-level security.
  • You are managing operational processes like intake requests, asset tracking, or budget approvals where each row is a record.
  • You need to hand off data between departments via automated row moves.

Choose Asana if:

  • Your team works best with lists, boards, and task assignments.
  • You need a clean, visual interface for daily task management.
  • You rely on forms to capture requests and want those to become tasks automatically.
  • You want a simpler permission model where everyone on a project sees the same tasks.

For a hybrid approach, some teams use Smartsheet for the backend data and Asana for the front-line task execution, syncing via a third-party integration like Zapier or a native connector. That adds complexity but leverages each tool’s strength.

Costs and Plans

Both offer free tiers and paid plans, but pricing structures differ. Smartsheet’s free plan allows up to 2 editors and 5 sheets. Paid plans (Pro, Business, Enterprise) add automation, cross-sheet references, and admin controls. Asana’s free plan allows up to 10 teammates and unlimited tasks, with basic rules. Paid plans (Premium, Business, Enterprise) add advanced rules, forms, timelines, and admin controls. Exact prices change frequently, so check the official pricing pages. For a small team, Asana’s free tier is more generous. For a large enterprise with complex data, Smartsheet’s per-sheet model can get expensive but offers more granular control.

Safety and Data Controls

Both tools are cloud-based and offer security features like SSO, two-factor authentication, and audit logs on enterprise plans. Smartsheet provides row-level and column-level permissions, which is a stronger safety control for sensitive data. Asana provides project-level privacy and the ability to restrict guests, but not field-level security. If you handle confidential client data, Smartsheet’s granular permissions are a safer choice. For both, you should set up regular data exports (CSV or API) to avoid vendor lock-in.

Alternatives to Consider

If neither tool fits, consider:

  • Monday.com: visually similar to Asana but with more customizable columns and automations.
  • Airtable: a database-spreadsheet hybrid that is more flexible than Smartsheet for relational data.
  • ClickUp: a feature-heavy tool that combines tasks, docs, and goals.
  • Trello: simpler and free, good for small teams that only need boards.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Smartsheet do Kanban boards like Asana?

Yes, Smartsheet has a Card view that displays rows as cards, and you can group by a column like Status. It works, but it’s not as fluid as Asana’s board view, which is designed specifically for drag-and-drop task management.

Can Asana handle complex formulas like Smartsheet?

No. Asana’s formula fields are limited to basic arithmetic on numeric custom fields. Smartsheet supports full spreadsheet formulas, cross-sheet references, and conditional logic, making it far more powerful for calculations.

Which tool is better for a marketing team?

Asana is generally better for marketing because it’s task-centric, has strong calendar and board views, and its forms make content requests easy. Smartsheet works if you need to track a large content inventory with many metadata fields, but it’s less intuitive for daily task assignments.

Can I restrict a user to only see certain rows in Smartsheet?

Yes, with a paid plan you can use row-level permissions to limit which rows a user can view or edit. Asana does not have row-level permissions; you would need to create separate projects or use private tasks.

Do both tools integrate with Slack and Google Workspace?

Yes, both have native integrations with Slack, Google Drive, Microsoft Teams, and many other apps. You can also use Zapier or Make to connect them to hundreds of other services.

Which tool is easier to learn for a non-technical team?

Asana is generally easier for non-technical teams because its interface is more visual and task-oriented. Smartsheet has a steeper learning curve due to spreadsheet formulas and row/column concepts, but teams already comfortable with Excel will find it familiar.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →