The Sony Walkman NW-ZX900 and the FiiO M23 are both premium digital audio players, but they target different priorities: the Sony excels in battery life, build quality, and a refined, warm sound signature, while the FiiO M23 offers more raw power, a wider feature set (including a desktop mode), and a more neutral, analytical tuning. If you value portability, long battery life, and a polished, comfortable listening experience, the Sony is the safer choice; if you need maximum power for demanding headphones and want the flexibility of a device that can also serve as a desktop DAC/amp, the FiiO is the more versatile pick.
Background: Two Different Philosophies
The NW-ZX900 (often called the ZX300 in some markets, though the ZX900 is the specific model with a 4.4mm balanced output) is part of Sony’s mid-to-high-end Walkman line. It inherits technology from Sony’s flagship WM1Z, including a custom S-Master HX digital amplifier and a high-quality chassis made of aluminum and copper. The M23, on the other hand, is FiiO’s latest in its M-series, a line known for packing as much hardware as possible into a portable form. FiiO’s approach is more “spec-sheet” driven, emphasizing DAC chips, amplifier power, and software features.
These two players are often compared because they sit in a similar price bracket (though the M23 is typically a bit cheaper) and both are considered “serious” upgrades over using a phone. But their design goals are distinct: Sony focuses on a curated, controlled listening experience with a signature sound, while FiiO aims for neutrality, power, and adaptability.
How They Work: Key Specs and Features
Before diving into the comparison, it’s worth understanding what each player offers under the hood.
- Sony NW-ZX900: Uses a custom S-Master HX digital amp, supports DSD and high-res PCM (up to 384kHz/32-bit), has a 4.4mm balanced output and a 3.5mm single-ended output, a 5-inch 720p display, and runs Android 9 (with Sony’s custom Walkman app). Battery life is rated at up to 30 hours on a single charge (balanced, MP3 128kbps).
- FiiO M23: Uses dual AKM AK4499EX DAC chips (a flagship-level DAC), supports up to 768kHz/32-bit PCM and DSD512, has 4.4mm balanced, 3.5mm single-ended, and also a 4.4mm line-out (for connecting to an external amp). It runs Android 12, has a 5.5-inch 1080p display, and includes a “Desktop Mode” that bypasses the battery when connected to USB power, allowing full power output without charging the internal battery. Battery life is around 10-12 hours balanced.
The M23’s spec sheet is clearly more impressive on paper, especially the DAC and the desktop mode. But the Sony’s battery life is a huge practical advantage for daily portability.
Sound Quality: Warm vs. Neutral
This is the most subjective and important area. The Sony NW-ZX900 has a warm, slightly colored sound. It’s smooth and forgiving, with a rich midrange and a soft treble that never becomes harsh. It’s a very “musical” sound that many people find immediately pleasing, especially for pop, rock, and jazz. The S-Master HX amp is known for its low distortion and its ability to drive sensitive IEMs without hiss.
The FiiO M23 is more neutral and analytical. It reveals more detail, has a wider soundstage, and provides more raw power (especially in balanced mode, it can deliver over 1000mW into 32 ohms). This makes it ideal for planars and hard-to-drive over-ear headphones. However, with sensitive IEMs, the M23 can be slightly bright or even harsh with poor recordings. It’s a more “reference” sound that lets you hear everything in the recording, warts and all.
Which is better? It depends on your headphones and your taste. If you have warm-sounding headphones, the FiiO’s neutrality will balance them out. If you have bright headphones, the Sony’s warmth will tame them.
How to Choose: A Practical Decision Guide
Here are the key factors to weigh when deciding between these two:
- Battery life: If you need a player that lasts a full day (or a long flight), the Sony wins easily (30h vs ~12h). The M23’s battery is a real weakness for portable use.
- Headphone impedance: If you primarily use IEMs or low-impedance headphones, the Sony is more than enough. If you own high-impedance (e.g., 300-ohm) or planar headphones, the FiiO M23’s power is essential.
- Desktop use: The M23’s Desktop Mode is a game-changer if you want a single device that serves as both a portable player and a desktop DAC/amp. The Sony doesn’t have this; it’s strictly portable.
- Software: The M23 runs a newer version of Android (12) and has access to more apps (including streaming services) out of the box. The Sony’s Android 9 is older, and while it can be updated, it’s less future-proof.
- Build quality: The Sony feels more premium in the hand, with its aluminum/copper chassis. The M23 is well-built but uses more plastic and feels lighter.
Common Problems and Misconceptions
One common misconception is that the Sony NW-ZX900 is “outdated” because it runs Android 9. While it’s true that it won’t get major Android updates, the Walkman app itself is still supported, and the player’s core function (playing music) is unaffected. Many users disable Wi-Fi to maximize battery life and treat it as a dedicated music player, not a mini-tablet.
Another issue with the M23 is its battery drain in portable mode. If you’re using it with a balanced cable and high-gain, you might get closer to 8 hours, which is still less than the Sony. Also, the M23’s desktop mode requires a specific USB-PD charger (with 12V/2A output) to work properly; using a standard charger will just charge the battery, not bypass it.
Finally, a note on “balanced” outputs: both players have 4.4mm balanced jacks. Balanced outputs can reduce crosstalk and provide more power, but they only matter if your headphones have a balanced cable. If you’re using the 3.5mm jack, the differences between the two players are less pronounced.
Alternatives to Consider
If neither player is a perfect fit, there are other options in the premium portable DAP market:
- For better battery life and a similar sound: The Sony NW-A306 (a cheaper, smaller Walkman with a similar tuning, though less powerful).
- For more power and a neutral sound: The iBasso DX170 or DX320 (if you want a more modular approach with swappable amp cards).
- For a pure streaming device: The Astell&Kern SR35 or SE180 (if you prefer AK’s tuning and build, though they are generally more expensive).
- For a budget option: The Shanling M3X or Hiby R5 Gen 2 offer good performance at a lower price, but with less power and build quality.
Costs and Value
The Sony NW-ZX900 typically retails for around $700–$800, while the FiiO M23 is usually around $600–$700. The M23 is cheaper and offers more raw hardware, but the Sony holds its value better on the used market and is often perceived as a more “premium” item. When considering cost, factor in accessories: you may need a good balanced cable for either player to get the most out of it, which can add $50–$200. Also, consider that the M23’s desktop mode means you might not need a separate desktop DAC/amp, potentially saving you money in the long run.
Safety and Care
Both players are safe to use, but there are a few things to keep in mind:
- Do not expose either player to extreme heat or moisture. The Sony has no official IP rating; the M23 is not rated either.
- When using the M23’s desktop mode, use a charger that meets the required specs (12V/2A) to avoid damage to the internal battery.
- Use a case or screen protector, as both players have glass fronts that can scratch.
- Do not leave the battery at 0% for long periods; store them at around 50% charge if not using for months.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the Sony NW-ZX900 stream Tidal or Spotify?
Yes, the Sony runs Android 9, so you can install Tidal, Spotify, Qobuz, and other streaming apps from the Google Play Store. However, the experience is slower than on a modern phone, and battery life drops significantly when streaming over Wi-Fi. The M23, with Android 12, handles streaming more smoothly.
Which player has better Bluetooth support?
The Sony supports LDAC (Sony’s high-resolution Bluetooth codec) and also supports aptX HD, aptX, AAC, and SBC. The M23 supports LDAC, aptX HD, aptX Adaptive, aptX, AAC, and SBC. Both are excellent, but the Sony’s LDAC implementation is slightly more stable in practice.
Can I use the FiiO M23 as a USB DAC for my computer?
Yes, the M23 can be used as a USB DAC. You connect it to your computer via USB, and it will appear as an audio device. It supports up to 768kHz/32-bit PCM and DSD512 over USB. The Sony NW-ZX900 also has a USB DAC function, but it’s limited to 384kHz/32-bit PCM and DSD128.
Which player is better for IEMs?
For sensitive IEMs, the Sony is generally a better match. It has a lower noise floor and a warmer tuning that prevents harshness. The M23’s higher output power can cause hiss with very sensitive IEMs, though you can use a low-gain setting to mitigate it.
Is the M23’s desktop mode really necessary?
Not necessary, but it’s a huge convenience. It allows you to use the M23 as a desktop DAC/amp without draining the battery, so you can leave it plugged in all the time without worrying about battery degradation. The Sony doesn’t have this feature, so if you use it as a desktop DAC, the battery will eventually die.
Which player has a better user interface?
The M23’s Android 12 is more modern and responsive, and it supports gesture navigation. The Sony’s Android 9 is older and uses a more traditional interface. However, the Sony’s Walkman app is very well-designed for music playback, with a focus on album art and a simple layout. If you mainly use the native music player, the Sony is arguably more pleasant to use.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Skip Ryobi and Milwaukee? Harbor Freight Tools to Buy
- Funny Subreddits That Make You Laugh
- Why Retro Gaming Is Still Worth Playing Today
- Neptune Facts That Will Blow Your Mind
- Survival Crafting Game Fatigue: Why & How to Fix It
- Sell Your EV Now Before Prices Plummet?