If you’re gaming on an AMD FX-9590, FX-8350, A10-7850K, or the first-generation Ryzen 5 1600, you may be losing more performance than you think—and the cost of sticking with them can exceed the price of a modern upgrade. This article compares the real-world gaming performance and total cost of ownership for these four CPUs against current budget options, so you can decide if an upgrade is worth it.
Why These Four Processors Are the Focus
These chips span two distinct eras of AMD. The FX-9590 and FX-8350 are from the Bulldozer/Piledriver architecture (2012–2013), while the A10-7850K is a Kaveri APU (2014) that combines CPU and GPU on one die. The Ryzen 5 1600 (2017) is the first-generation Zen. All four are still common in budget gaming PCs because they were inexpensive and widely sold, but they now bottleneck modern graphics cards and fail to maintain 60 fps in many current titles.
Gaming performance depends not just on core count but on single-thread speed, cache, and memory support. These older chips lack the IPC (instructions per clock) and memory bandwidth that newer architectures provide, which directly affects frame rates in CPU-bound games like esports titles and open-world simulators.
How Much Performance Are You Actually Losing?
In CPU-bound scenarios (e.g., 1080p with a high-end GPU), the FX-9590 and FX-8350 often deliver 30–50% lower frame rates than a modern budget chip like the Ryzen 5 5600. The A10-7850K, with its weak CPU cores, is even slower. The Ryzen 5 1600 is closer to modern chips but still trails the Ryzen 5 5600 by about 20–30% in gaming due to lower IPC and slower memory support.
Concrete example: in a game like Counter-Strike 2, an FX-8350 might average 80–100 fps, while a Ryzen 5 5600 easily exceeds 200 fps with the same GPU. In Cyberpunk 2077, the FX chip may drop below 40 fps in dense areas, while the Ryzen 5 5600 holds 60+ fps. These differences are not just about high refresh rates—they affect 1% lows, causing stutters and hitches that make games feel unresponsive.
The Hidden Cost of Keeping an Old CPU
Sticking with these processors can cost you more than an upgrade in several ways:
- Power consumption: The FX-9590 draws up to 220W under load, compared to a Ryzen 5 5600’s 65W. Over a year of daily gaming (say 3 hours/day), the FX-9590 can consume about 150 kWh more than the Ryzen 5 5600. At an average electricity rate, that’s roughly $20–30 per year—small, but it adds up over 3–4 years.
- Cooling costs: The FX chips run hot and often require aftermarket coolers ($30–50) and better case airflow. A modern chip can use the stock cooler.
- Motherboard and RAM: To upgrade from FX, you need a new motherboard and DDR4 RAM (or DDR5 on newest platforms). That’s an additional $100–150, but even with that, a full platform switch (CPU + board + RAM) costs around $250–300 for a Ryzen 5 5600 combo, which is often less than the cumulative extra electricity and cooling over 3 years.
- Performance loss in productivity: Video editing, streaming, and compiling are significantly slower on these old chips, costing you time if you use the PC for work.
Let’s do a rough cost comparison over 3 years for an FX-8350 system (assuming 3 hours gaming/day, 0.15 USD/kWh):
- Extra electricity vs. Ryzen 5 5600: ~$20/year × 3 = $60
- Aftermarket cooler (if not already owned): $40
- Total extra cost of keeping: ~$100
- Cost of upgrading to Ryzen 5 5600 + B550 motherboard + 16GB DDR4: ~$250–300 (as of 2024, but prices vary)
- If you sell your old CPU, board, and RAM for ~$50–80, the net upgrade cost is ~$170–250.
So the upgrade pays for itself in about 2–3 years just in electricity and cooling, and you also get a massive performance boost. The longer you wait, the more you lose.
When an Upgrade Might Not Be Necessary
There are scenarios where sticking with these CPUs is still reasonable:
- You only play older or indie games that are not CPU-intensive (e.g., Minecraft (single-threaded but playable), Terraria, Stardew Valley).
- You have a low-end GPU (e.g., GTX 1050 Ti or RX 560) that is the bottleneck anyway, so the CPU doesn’t limit you.
- You’re on a very tight budget and can’t afford even a $250 upgrade, but you can still enjoy games at lower settings.
- You use the PC for basic tasks (web, office) and gaming is secondary.
But if you play modern AAA titles, competitive shooters, or want to stream, an upgrade is strongly recommended.
What Should You Upgrade To? (Budget Options)
As of 2024, the best budget gaming CPU is the AMD Ryzen 5 5600 (6 cores, 12 threads) – it offers excellent gaming performance for around $130–150. Pair it with a B550 motherboard ($80–100) and 16GB DDR4-3200 ($30–40). Total: ~$250–290. This is a massive jump from any of the four CPUs discussed.
If you’re on an even tighter budget, the Ryzen 5 5500 (around $100) is also good, but it has less cache and is slightly slower. For Intel, the Core i5-12400F (around $110–130) is another strong option, but you’ll need a new LGA1700 motherboard and DDR4 or DDR5 RAM.
For those upgrading from the Ryzen 5 1600, you may be able to keep your AM4 motherboard and just update the BIOS to support a Ryzen 5 5600 – that’s a much cheaper upgrade (just the CPU, ~$150). Check your motherboard manufacturer’s website for compatibility.
Common Problems with These Old CPUs
Beyond performance, these processors have known issues:
- High temperatures: The FX-9590 and FX-8350 run very hot under load, often exceeding 70°C, and can throttle if cooling is inadequate. The A10-7850K also runs warm due to the integrated GPU.
- Motherboard VRM strain: The FX-9590 draws enormous power (220W), which can overheat cheap motherboard VRMs, causing system instability or shutdowns.
- Memory compatibility: First-gen Ryzen (like the 1600) is picky about RAM speeds; running above 2933 MHz can be unstable without manual tuning.
- Lack of modern instruction sets: These CPUs lack AVX2 (FX and Kaveri) or have limited AVX2 (Ryzen 1st gen), which some modern games and emulators require.
How to Decide If It’s Time to Upgrade
Ask yourself these questions:
- Do I play games released in the last 2-3 years? If yes, you’re likely leaving performance on the table.
- Is my GPU usage below 90% in games? If your GPU isn’t maxed out, your CPU is the bottleneck.
- Do I experience stutters or frame drops in CPU-heavy scenes? That’s a classic sign of CPU limitation.
- Can I afford a $250 upgrade? If yes, the long-term savings and experience justify it.
- Am I willing to sell my old parts to offset the cost? That can make the upgrade more affordable.
If you answered yes to most, plan your upgrade. If not, you can continue using your current system, but be aware that future games will demand more.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the FX-8350 still good for gaming in 2024?
No, the FX-8350 is not good for modern gaming. It lacks single-thread performance and modern instruction sets, causing low frame rates and stutters in most games released after 2019. It can handle older titles and light esports games at low settings, but it’s a significant bottleneck with any mid-range or better GPU.
Can I upgrade my Ryzen 5 1600 to a Ryzen 5 5600 without a new motherboard?
Yes, if you have a B350, B450, X370, or X470 motherboard, you can update the BIOS to support Ryzen 5000 series CPUs. However, not all boards have received the update, so check your motherboard manufacturer’s website. You may also need to update the BIOS using an older CPU first, which can be a hassle.
Is the A10-7850K good for anything?
The A10-7850K is only useful for a basic office PC or as a media center. Its integrated GPU is weaker than even a low-end dedicated graphics card, so it’s not suitable for gaming beyond very old or 2D titles. It also consumes a lot of power for its performance.
How much does it cost to upgrade from an FX-8350 to a modern system?
As of 2024, a budget upgrade to a Ryzen 5 5600, B550 motherboard, and 16GB DDR4 RAM costs around $250–300. If you reuse your old case, power supply, and storage, that’s the total. You can sell your old CPU, board, and RAM for about $50–80, bringing the net cost down to $170–250.
Will a new CPU improve my FPS if my GPU is also old?
If your GPU is very old (e.g., GTX 960 or older), the GPU will likely be the bottleneck, so a new CPU alone won’t boost FPS significantly. However, a new CPU will reduce stutters and improve minimum frame rates, making the game feel smoother. Ideally, you should balance both components.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Microsoft Surface Duo: The Foldable Phone Story
- Samsung SM-T813 Hard Reset: Step-by-Step Guide
- Mafia Clash Codes: Real Meanings & Usage
- Remove Programs from Mac: Full Uninstall Guide
- Project Sentinel Morning Digest: Data Stack Failure Alerts
- Best KVM VPS Hosting: Top Picks & Guide