keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Stop Giving Websites Your Real Email?

Card No. 06·72008 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Yes, you should stop giving websites your real email address in most cases, and use a temporary or alias email service instead. This protects you from spam, data breaches, and targeted tracking while still letting you receive the confirmation links and account emails you need. The trade-off is a little extra setup time, but the privacy and security benefits are significant.

Why Your Real Email Is Valuable

Your email address is more than just a way to receive messages. It is the key to your online identity. Most accounts are tied to an email address, and if a website is breached, your email address can be combined with other leaked data (like passwords or phone numbers) to build a detailed profile of you. This profile can be used for targeted phishing attacks, spam, or even identity theft. Additionally, many companies sell or share your email with third-party advertisers, which is why you suddenly get newsletters from companies you never signed up for.

How Email Aliases Work

An email alias is a different address that forwards messages to your real inbox. There are two main types: simple aliases and plus-addresses. Simple aliases are completely separate addresses (e.g., shopping123@protonmail.com) that you create through a service like SimpleLogin or AnonAddy. Plus-addresses are a feature of your own email provider—for example, if your real email is john@gmail.com, you can use john+shopping@gmail.com. Gmail and Outlook ignore everything after the plus sign, so the mail still arrives in your inbox, but you can filter on it. However, plus-addresses are easy to spot and strip, so they don’t protect you from a site that deliberately removes them.

When to Use a Temporary Email

Temporary email services (like Guerrilla Mail or 10 Minute Mail) give you a throwaway address that self-destructs after a short time. These are perfect for one-time downloads, reading a paywalled article, or signing up for a service you’ll never use again. But they have a major drawback: you can’t reset a password if you forget it, and you won’t get any important updates. So, never use a temporary email for anything you might need to recover later, like a bank account, a government portal, or a work-related service.

How to Choose an Alias Service

If you want a permanent alias that forwards to your real inbox, you have several options. Some are free, some are paid, and they differ in features. Here are the key factors to consider:

  • Cost: Free tiers usually limit the number of aliases (e.g., 10) and may not allow custom domains. Paid plans (around $1–$5/month) offer unlimited aliases and custom domains.
  • Privacy: Look for services that don’t log your IP address and have a clear no-logs policy. Some services are based in privacy-friendly jurisdictions (like Switzerland or the EU).
  • Integration: Some alias services integrate with password managers (like Bitwarden) so you can generate a new alias on the fly when signing up for a site.
  • Reply capability: Some services allow you to reply from the alias, while others only forward incoming mail. If you need to reply, make sure the service supports it.
  • Ease of use: Browser extensions and mobile apps make it easier to create an alias when you need it.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

One common misconception is that using an alias is against the terms of service of some websites. While it’s true that some sites (like certain forums or marketplaces) prohibit throwaway emails, most don’t care. Another issue is that some websites block known temporary email domains, so you’ll need a real-looking alias from a service like SimpleLogin or 33Mail. Also, be aware that if you use an alias and lose access to it (e.g., the service shuts down), you could lose access to accounts that rely on that alias for password resets. To mitigate this, keep a list of which alias you used for which account, and consider using a custom domain so you can move your aliases to another provider if needed.

Costs and Trade-offs

The cost of using email aliases is mostly time and a little bit of mental overhead. Free services are fine for most people, but if you want more control, a paid plan is cheap. The bigger trade-off is that you have to manage your aliases—remembering which one you used for which service, and periodically cleaning up old ones. But this is a small price to pay for keeping your real inbox clean and reducing the risk of spam and phishing. On the other hand, the cost of using your real email everywhere is much higher: you’ll spend time unsubscribing from newsletters, deleting spam, and worrying about data breaches.

Safety and Security Considerations

Using an alias does not make you anonymous. The website you sign up for still sees your IP address and can track you via cookies and browser fingerprinting. An alias only protects your email address. Also, if you use a free alias service, make sure it uses encryption (HTTPS) and has a good reputation. Some free services may sell your data or show ads. Always read the privacy policy. Finally, never use an alias for critical accounts like banking or government services unless you are absolutely sure you can recover it. For those, it’s safer to use your real email and enable two-factor authentication.

Alternatives to Aliases

If you don’t want to use an alias, there are other ways to reduce spam:

  • Use a separate email for subscriptions: Create a free Gmail or Outlook account just for newsletters and online shopping.
  • Use a password manager with built-in email masking: Some password managers (like Bitwarden) offer a feature that creates a random email alias for you.
  • Unsubscribe properly: Use the unsubscribe link at the bottom of legitimate emails, but be aware that spammers may not honor it.
  • Use a custom domain: If you own a domain, you can create any email address you want (e.g., amazon@yourdomain.com) and forward it to your real inbox. This gives you unlimited aliases and full control.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it legal to use a fake email address?

Yes, it’s legal to use an alias or a temporary email address for most purposes. However, you shouldn’t use a fake email to deceive someone in a way that causes harm (e.g., fraud). For signing up for services, it’s generally acceptable, though some sites’ terms may require a valid email.

Can I use a plus-address for every site?

You can, but it’s not always effective. Some websites strip the plus sign and everything after it, so you’ll end up with your real email anyway. Also, spammers know about plus-addresses and may remove them. It’s better to use a separate alias service for sites you don’t trust.

What happens if an alias service shuts down?

If you’re using a free alias service and it shuts down, you’ll lose all your aliases. Any account that uses those aliases will become unrecoverable if you need a password reset. To avoid this, use a service that allows you to export your aliases, or use a custom domain so you can redirect to a new provider.

Will using an alias stop all spam?

No, but it will significantly reduce it. Some spam is sent to random addresses or harvested from other sources, so you might still get some. However, if you use a unique alias for each site, you can easily identify which site leaked your email and block that alias.

Can I reply to emails from an alias?

It depends on the service. Some alias services allow you to reply, and the reply will appear to come from the alias. Others only forward incoming mail, so you’d have to reply from your real email. Check the service’s features before you commit.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →