keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Mortuary Assistant Alternatives: 3 Horror Games for Clue Hunters

Card No. 06·83400 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

If you loved the forensic investigation and clue-hunting in The Mortuary Assistant, you’re looking for horror games that reward careful observation, deduction, and piecing together a story from environmental details. This article names three direct alternatives—Observation, Stories Untold, and Painscreek Killings—then explains why each fits the clue-hunter niche, how they differ in gameplay, and what to expect before you buy.

Why The Mortuary Assistant Resonates with Clue Hunters

The Mortuary Assistant (2022) puts you in the role of an embalmer’s assistant who must identify which corpse is possessed by examining bodies, reading files, and noting subtle changes across repeated playthroughs. The core loop is pure deduction: you gather observations, cross-reference them with a manual, and make a judgment under time pressure. That blend of methodical investigation and supernatural dread is exactly what the three games below replicate in different settings.

Alternative 1: Observation (Sci-Fi Mystery)

Observation (2019) casts you as S.A.M., the AI aboard a damaged space station. You’re not a human with a flashlight—you’re the ship’s camera system, able to access feeds, override doors, and read crew messages. The clue-hunting comes from piecing together what happened to the crew from security footage, audio logs, and data files. You literally control the investigation tools, which makes the discovery feel earned.

Why it fits: like The Mortuary Assistant, you’re given a confined environment and a mystery that unfolds through direct observation. The game never holds your hand; you must notice inconsistencies (a missing object, a corrupted file) and act on them. It’s shorter (about 5–7 hours) and more linear, but the “aha” moments are just as satisfying.

Alternative 2: Stories Untold (Text-Based Horror)

Stories Untold (2017) is a compilation of four episodes, each a different horror vignette. The first episode, The House Abandon, is the one most relevant to clue hunters: you sit at a computer terminal and interact with a text adventure describing a house, while a separate window shows your character’s surroundings. The puzzle is figuring out how the text commands affect the real world—a literal exercise in reading clues and testing hypotheses.

Why it fits: the game forces you to parse written descriptions for hidden meaning, much like reading autopsy notes in The Mortuary Assistant. It’s slower, more cerebral, and the horror comes from dread rather than jump scares. Each episode is short (1–2 hours), but the combined experience offers variety in how clues are presented.

Alternative 3: The Painscreek Killings (Open-World Investigation)

The Painscreek Killings (2017) is the most direct “clue hunter” game on this list. You play a journalist investigating a decades-old murder in an abandoned town. There are no combat mechanics, no NPCs to talk to—only the environment. You read letters, examine photographs, unlock doors with keys you find, and gradually reconstruct the timeline of the crime. The game expects you to take notes and form your own conclusions.

Why it fits: it’s the closest to the “detective” fantasy that The Mortuary Assistant touches. The town is large and non-linear, so you must decide what to investigate and in what order. The payoff is a complete narrative that you assemble yourself, not one that’s fed to you in cutscenes. It’s longer (8–10 hours) and has no supernatural elements, but the satisfaction of solving the case is purely intellectual.

How to Choose Among Them

Your choice depends on what you liked most about The Mortuary Assistant:

  • If you enjoyed the sci-fi setting and using tools to find clues → choose Observation.
  • If you liked reading text and interpreting ambiguous descriptions → choose Stories Untold.
  • If you want a pure, non-linear detective game with no supernatural elements → choose The Painscreek Killings.

All three are single-player, story-driven, and available on PC (Steam). None require fast reflexes—they’re about thinking, not twitch skills.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

A frequent misconception is that Observation is a walking simulator. It’s not—you have agency in how you investigate, but the game is linear in its story beats. Another is that Stories Untold is a text adventure in the old-school sense; it actually uses a modern interface with graphics and sound, and the text commands are part of the puzzle, not the entire game. For The Painscreek Killings, some players get stuck because they don’t realize they can take notes in-game; the game doesn’t auto-log clues, so you must write things down yourself. That’s a feature, not a bug—it forces you to be an active investigator.

Safety and Comfort Notes

All three games contain mature themes: Observation has body horror and psychological tension, Stories Untold has disturbing imagery and audio, and The Painscreek Killings deals with murder and its aftermath. None are graphically violent in the style of gore-fests, but the atmosphere is heavy. If you’re sensitive to dark themes, play in short sessions and keep the lights on. Also, Observation and Stories Untold have sudden loud noises—consider lowering your volume if that bothers you.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are these games scary in the same way as The Mortuary Assistant?

Not exactly. The Mortuary Assistant relies on jump scares and a constant sense of being watched. Observation and Stories Untold build dread through atmosphere and story, while The Painscreek Killings is more of a mystery thriller than a horror game. If you want the same level of supernatural fear, Observation comes closest.

Do I need to play The Mortuary Assistant first to understand these?

No. All three are standalone games with no connection to The Mortuary Assistant. You can play them in any order.

Which game has the most replay value for clue hunters?

The Painscreek Killings has the most because the town is large and you can miss clues, leading to different conclusions. Observation and Stories Untold are more linear, so once you know the solution, replaying is less rewarding.

Are there any other games like these?

Yes. If you enjoy the note-taking investigation, try Her Story or Return of the Obra Dinn. If you want more environmental storytelling, Gone Home and Firewatch are similar in tone but less horror-focused.

Can I play these on console?

Observation is available on PlayStation 4 and Xbox One. Stories Untold is on Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, and Xbox One. The Painscreek Killings is currently PC-only.

How long are these games?

Approximate playtimes: Observation 5–7 hours, Stories Untold 3–5 hours for all episodes, The Painscreek Killings 8–12 hours depending on how thorough you are.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →