keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Uncharted vs Tomb Raider: Which Adventure Series Should You Play?

Card No. 06·81317 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

If you want a tightly scripted, cinematic blockbuster with set-piece spectacle, play Uncharted; if you prefer exploration, optional tombs, and a more methodical survival tone, play Tomb Raider. Both series deliver third-person action-adventure with puzzle solving, climbing, and shooting, but they differ in pacing, tone, and how much freedom they give you. This article breaks down those differences so you can pick the right one for your taste.

Background: Two Flagships of the Genre

Uncharted is a Sony first-party series developed by Naughty Dog, debuting in 2007 with Uncharted: Drake’s Fortune on PlayStation 3. It stars Nathan Drake, a wisecracking treasure hunter who travels the world in search of lost cities and legendary artifacts. The series is known for its Hollywood-style action, with massive set pieces, scripted chases, and a focus on character banter.

Tomb Raider is older, debuting in 1996 on Sega Saturn and PlayStation, created by Core Design and now developed by Crystal Dynamics. It stars archaeologist Lara Croft, who has evolved from a polygonal icon into a more grounded survivor. The modern trilogy (2013, Rise of the Tomb Raider, Shadow of the Tomb Raider) rebooted the character, emphasizing stealth, crafting, and exploration of large hub areas.

Both series have been remastered and re-released on modern platforms, so you can play them on PS4/PS5, Xbox, and PC (Uncharted 4 and Lost Legacy are on PC via the Legacy of Thieves Collection).

How the Gameplay Differs

Uncharted is a linear, guided experience. You follow a narrow path, with occasional branches that hide collectibles. Combat is cover-based shooting, and the platforming is automatic – you press jump at the right moment and Nathan does the rest. The difficulty comes from timing and enemy waves, not from figuring out where to go.

Tomb Raider (modern trilogy) gives you more agency. The maps are larger, with optional challenge tombs that require you to solve a puzzle to get a reward. You can upgrade Lara’s gear, craft arrows and medkits, and choose between stealth or direct combat. The platforming is more manual – you must aim your jumps and sometimes use tools like a climbing axe.

In short: Uncharted is a rollercoaster ride; Tomb Raider is a jungle expedition.

Story and Tone: Which Resonates More?

Uncharted leans into pulp adventure. The dialogue is witty, the villains are theatrical, and the stakes are often global (or mythical). The tone is lighthearted even when the situation is dire – Nathan quips while hanging from a cliff. The emotional beats land because you care about the characters, especially the relationship between Nathan, Elena, and Sully.

Tomb Raider (reboot) is darker and more serious. The 2013 game starts with Lara as a terrified survivor on an island, and she becomes a killer out of necessity. The later games explore themes of grief, duty, and colonialism (though not always critically). The tone is somber, with fewer jokes and more internal monologue. If you prefer a character who grows through trauma, Lara’s arc is more substantial.

Which Series Should You Choose? A Quick Decision Guide

  • Pick Uncharted if: you want a cinematic, linear story with constant action, memorable characters, and no backtracking. You enjoy set pieces like train derailments and plane crashes.
  • Pick Tomb Raider if: you like exploring large environments, solving environmental puzzles, and upgrading your gear. You don’t mind some backtracking and prefer a more solitary, survivalist feel.
  • Pick both if: you have time – they complement each other well. Start with Uncharted for a quick thrill, then move to Tomb Raider for depth.

Common Problems and How to Avoid Them

One common frustration in Uncharted is the shooting – the AI can be spongy, and the cover system sometimes sticks to the wrong wall. Tip: use the shoulder aim and don’t be afraid to move between covers; grenades are your friend. On higher difficulties, the game becomes a cover-shooter, so be patient.

In Tomb Raider, players often get lost in the hub areas. Tip: use the survival instincts (highlighting interactive objects) and fast-travel camps. Also, the optional tombs are easy to miss – if you want the full experience, explore every nook. Another issue is the combat: stealth is underpowered at times, so don’t be afraid to go loud.

Costs and Availability

Both series are available on current consoles and PC. Uncharted: The Nathan Drake Collection (1-3) is often bundled, and Uncharted 4 and Lost Legacy are sold together as the Legacy of Thieves Collection. Tomb Raider: Definitive Edition (2013), Rise, and Shadow are sold separately, but they frequently go on sale on Steam and console stores. Prices vary by platform and sales, but you can often get each game for under $20 during promotions. If you have a PS Plus subscription, some Uncharted games are included in the catalog.

Alternatives: What Else to Play

If you like Uncharted, try the Star Wars Jedi series (Jedi: Fallen Order and Survivor) for a similar mix of platforming and combat, or God of War (2018) for a more grounded story with a father-son dynamic. If you prefer Tomb Raider’s exploration, try Horizon Zero Dawn for its open world and bow combat, or The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild for pure exploration and puzzle solving. For a more mature take on treasure hunting, Outer Wilds (no combat) or The Forgotten City offer narrative-driven mysteries.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Uncharted and Tomb Raider in the same universe?

No. They are separate franchises owned by Sony (Uncharted) and Square Enix (Tomb Raider) – though Tomb Raider is now under Embracer Group. There are occasional easter eggs referencing each other, but no canonical crossover.

Do I need to play all games in order?

For Uncharted, yes – the story arcs across the series, especially 1-3 and then 4. You can skip the first one if you want, but you’ll miss character introductions. For Tomb Raider, the modern trilogy is a reboot, so you can start with the 2013 game and play in order; the older games are separate and not required.

Which has better graphics?

Both look great, but Uncharted 4 and Lost Legacy are often considered technical showcases on PS4/PS5. Tomb Raider: Shadow also has impressive visuals, especially in jungle environments. It’s a tie – it depends on the art style you prefer.

Can I play them on PC?

Yes. Uncharted: Legacy of Thieves Collection (4 and Lost Legacy) is on PC, but the first three are not officially. Tomb Raider (all three reboot games) are on PC, and the classic games are available on GOG and Steam.

Which has better puzzles?

Tomb Raider, by a wide margin. The optional tombs are clever and require observation and physics. Uncharted’s puzzles are simpler and often just rotate symbols or align mirrors – they’re more like interactive cutscenes.

Is Uncharted too easy?

On normal difficulty, yes – the combat is forgiving and the platforming is automatic. But on Crushing difficulty, it’s brutally hard. Tomb Raider offers a more consistent challenge, especially on hard mode where enemies are more aggressive and resources are scarce.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →