For gripping and turning stubborn fasteners, you should use adjustable pliers (often called crescent wrenches) when you need a secure, non-marring grip on a nut or bolt, and vice grips (locking pliers) when you need to clamp something firmly in place or free a seized fastener that requires maximum torque. The right choice depends on whether you need continuous adjustability or a locked, hands-free grip.
What Are Vice Grips?
Vice grips, formally known as locking pliers, are a hand tool with an adjustable, self-locking jaw. They were invented in the early 20th century and have become a staple in workshops and toolboxes. The key feature is a compound lever mechanism: after you set the jaw opening with a screw at the base of the handle, squeezing the handles together locks the jaws shut with a specific amount of force. A release lever on the handle unlocks them.
This locking action means the tool stays clamped without continuous hand pressure. You can set it down, use both hands elsewhere, or apply significant torque through the handles without worrying about the grip slipping. The jaws are typically serrated and can be straight, curved, or needle-nose, and some models have a wire cutter built into the jaw base.
What Are Adjustable Pliers?
Adjustable pliers, often generically called “crescent wrenches” (after a popular brand), are a type of wrench with a movable jaw that slides along a track. You turn a small worm screw to adjust the jaw opening to fit a specific fastener size. Unlike locking pliers, they do not lock closed; they rely on your hand grip to maintain pressure on the fastener.
There are two main categories: the classic adjustable wrench, which has a flat jaw at a 15-degree angle to the handle, and slip-joint pliers, which have a pivot point that can be moved to one of several positions to increase the jaw opening. Both are designed for turning nuts, bolts, and other fasteners, and they are typically smoother-jawed than locking pliers, making them less likely to damage the fastener’s head.
Key Differences: Locking vs. Continuous Grip
The fundamental difference is the grip mechanism. Vice grips lock shut; adjustable pliers do not. This leads to several practical differences:
- Torque and Slippage: Vice grips, when locked, can transmit very high torque without slipping, but they will mar the fastener. Adjustable pliers can also transmit high torque, but the jaw can slip if you don’t maintain a firm grip, especially on rounded fasteners.
- Hands-Free Operation: Vice grips can be left clamped on a workpiece, freeing your hands. Adjustable pliers require constant hand pressure.
- Adjustability: Adjustable pliers offer infinite adjustment within their range, so you can fine-tune the fit to a fastener. Vice grips have a screw adjustment, but the range is more coarse, and you often need to test and adjust several times to get the right clamping force.
- Damage to Fasteners: The serrated jaws of vice grips will dig into the metal of a bolt or nut, often ruining it. Adjustable pliers, with their smoother jaws, are much gentler and are the preferred choice for fasteners you want to reuse.
When to Use Vice Grips
Reach for vice grips when you need a temporary clamp or when you’re dealing with a fastener that is already damaged or seized. Common scenarios include:
- Removing a rounded-off bolt or nut: If the head is already stripped, the aggressive serrations of locking pliers can often bite into the remaining metal and get a grip.
- Clamping two pieces together: For gluing, welding, or drilling, vice grips can act as a quick-release clamp, holding parts securely while you work.
- Holding a bolt in place: When you need to tighten a nut on the other side, locking pliers can hold the bolt head so it doesn’t spin.
- As a temporary handle: On a broken lever, a stuck valve stem, or a stripped screw, locking pliers can provide a firm grip to turn or pull.
Always use the smallest pair that fits the job, and be aware that the locking mechanism can exert a lot of force, potentially crushing softer materials.
When to Use Adjustable Pliers
Adjustable pliers are the go-to for everyday fastener work, especially when you care about not damaging the fastener. Use them when:
- Turning nuts and bolts: For general assembly, disassembly, or adjustment, an adjustable wrench provides a solid, non-marring grip.
- Working with plumbing fittings: The smooth jaws are ideal for chrome or brass fixtures, where you want to avoid scratches.
- When you need a quick size change: The worm screw lets you quickly adapt to different fastener sizes without switching tools.
- For light to medium torque: For most household tasks, the grip you can apply by hand is sufficient, and the tool is lighter and easier to maneuver than locking pliers.
The main drawback is that the jaw can slip if you apply too much force, especially on a rounded fastener. Always pull the wrench toward you, and adjust the jaw so it fits snugly on the fastener’s flats, not on a corner.
Common Problems and Misconceptions
One common misconception is that vice grips are a good substitute for a proper wrench. While they can remove a stripped bolt, they will almost certainly destroy the head further, and they are not meant for precise torque application. Using them on a good fastener will ruin it.
Another issue is jaw slippage on adjustable pliers. This usually happens because the wrench is adjusted too large, or because you’re pulling at an angle. Always adjust the jaw to fit the fastener exactly, and pull the handle so the force is applied to the fixed jaw, not the movable one.
Also, be aware that both tools can be damaged by over-torquing. Vice grips can have their locking mechanism fail, and adjustable pliers can have their worm screw strip. Always use the correct size tool for the job, and if you’re applying extreme force, consider a six-point socket wrench or a breaker bar.
How to Choose the Right Tool
To decide, ask yourself two questions: Do I need to hold this without my hand? And, do I care about damaging the fastener?
- If you need a hands-free clamp, or the fastener is already ruined, choose vice grips.
- If you need to turn a good fastener without marring it, choose adjustable pliers.
- For a seized bolt that you plan to replace, vice grips can provide the extra bite you need.
- For a delicate fitting, like a gas line or a polished nut, always use adjustable pliers, and consider wrapping the jaws with tape for extra protection.
In a well-stocked toolbox, both tools have a place. They are not interchangeable; they are complementary.
Safety and Best Practices
Both tools can cause injury if misused. Always wear safety glasses, as broken tools or slipping jaws can send metal fragments flying. When using vice grips, be aware that the locking mechanism can suddenly release, causing the tool to slip. When using adjustable pliers, never use a pipe or hammer to extend the handle for extra torque, as this can break the tool or cause it to slip violently.
Keep the tools clean and lightly oiled. Check for wear on the jaws and the adjusting mechanism. A worn tool is more likely to slip, which can lead to skinned knuckles or damaged workpieces.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use vice grips on a bolt I want to reuse?
It’s not recommended. The serrated jaws will leave deep grooves in the bolt head, which will likely ruin it. If you need to reuse the bolt, use an adjustable wrench or a properly sized socket wrench.
Why do adjustable pliers slip off rounded nuts?
Because the jaws are smooth, they don’t bite into the metal. On a rounded nut, there isn’t enough flat surface for the jaws to grip. You can try tightening the adjustment, but for a truly rounded nut, vice grips are often the only tool that will work.
Are vice grips better for removing stripped screws?
Yes, often they are. The locking grip and serrated jaws can grab onto the sides of a stripped screw head. However, they may not fit in tight spaces where a screw extractor would be needed. For a screw that’s flush with the surface, you’ll need a different approach.
What is the difference between a crescent wrench and adjustable pliers?
The terms are often used interchangeably, but a crescent wrench is a specific type of adjustable pliers with a flat, angled jaw. Slip-joint pliers, on the other hand, have a curved jaw and a pivot that can be repositioned. Both are adjustable pliers, but they have different jaw shapes and are used for different tasks.
Can I use adjustable pliers as a hammer?
No. Using any pliers as a hammer can damage the tool’s mechanism and the jaws, and it’s a safety hazard. Use a proper hammer for striking tasks.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Car Trends Making Cars Worse: 7 Downsides
- Nostalgic Classic Games Revamped on G2A?
- Nvidia RTX 4000 Super GPUs: Full Specs & Buying Guide
- Photoshop vs Lightroom AI Features Compared
- DNF vs DNF5: Which Package Manager?
- Korean SUV Making BMW and Audi Owners Question Their Choices?