Before buying Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac preferred shares, you need to know that they are not ordinary bank preferred stocks: they are perpetual, non-cumulative preferreds of government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs) under conservatorship, with dividends that can be suspended at any time and no legal obligation to ever resume them. This article explains the key risks, the mechanics of the securities, how they differ from common shares, and what to check before you invest.
A Quick Background on the GSEs and Their Preferreds
Fannie Mae (Federal National Mortgage Association) and Freddie Mac (Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation) are congressionally chartered companies that buy and guarantee mortgages. Since September 2008, both have been in federal conservatorship under the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA). During the 2008 financial crisis, the U.S. Treasury injected about $189 billion into the two companies in exchange for senior preferred shares and warrants. In 2012, the Treasury amended the agreements to sweep nearly all of their profits—the so-called “net worth sweep.”
Both companies have several series of preferred stock (e.g., Fannie Mae Series S, Freddie Mac Series Z), each with a par value (usually $25 or $50) and a fixed or adjustable dividend rate. These preferreds are “perpetual,” meaning they have no maturity date; they can be called (redeemed) by the company at par after a certain date, but they do not have to be.
How the Preferred Shares Work
Preferred shares sit between common stock and debt in the capital structure. They pay a fixed dividend—for example, Fannie Mae Series S pays an annual dividend of 7.00% of par ($1.75 per share on a $25 par). Dividends are paid quarterly, but they are non-cumulative: if the company misses a dividend, it has no obligation to pay it later. In the case of the GSEs, the conservatorship effectively allows the FHFA to direct the companies to suspend dividends. In fact, dividends on all non-Treasury preferreds have been suspended since 2008.
Because the preferreds are non-cumulative, a missed dividend is lost forever. If the companies were to exit conservatorship and resume dividends, they would not be required to pay any back dividends. This is a critical difference from cumulative preferreds, which accrue missed payments.
Key Risks You Must Understand
- Dividend suspension: Dividends can be stopped at any time, and there is no guarantee they will ever resume. They have been suspended since 2008.
- No maturity: You cannot force the company to buy back your shares. The only way to get your principal back is to sell on the open market or wait for a call, which is unlikely in the near term.
- Subordination: In a liquidation, preferred shareholders are paid after all debt and senior preferred (Treasury) but before common shareholders. However, given the GSEs’ structure, the practical recovery is uncertain.
- Conservatorship uncertainty: The future of the GSEs is a political and legal question. Changes in law, regulation, or a new conservatorship agreement could affect the value of the preferreds.
- Market volatility: These shares trade on the OTC market (e.g., FNMAT, FMCKJ) and can be highly volatile, with wide bid-ask spreads. Prices have swung dramatically on news about potential GSE reform.
How to Choose a Series
If you are still considering an investment, you need to compare the different series. Each series has a different dividend rate (some are fixed, some are adjustable), a different par value, a different call date, and a different liquidation preference. Here are the factors to compare:
- Dividend rate and type: Fixed-rate preferreds pay a constant percentage of par; adjustable-rate preferreds reset periodically (e.g., based on 3-month LIBOR or SOFR plus a spread).
- Call date: The earliest date the company can redeem at par. If the company redeems, you get par, not a premium.
- Current yield: Annual dividend divided by current price. Because prices fluctuate, the yield can be much higher than the stated rate.
- Liquidity: Some series trade more actively than others. Check the average daily volume.
- Par value: $25 or $50 par affects the dollar amount of the dividend and the call price.
For example, Fannie Mae Series S (FNMAT) has a $25 par, pays a fixed 7.00% dividend ($1.75/year), and is callable. Freddie Mac Series Z (FMCKJ) has a $25 par and pays a fixed 7.875% dividend ($1.96875/year). The current market prices are far below par—often in the $5–$10 range—so the current yield is much higher than the stated rate, but that yield is only realized if dividends resume.
Common Misconceptions
One common misconception is that the preferreds are “guaranteed” by the government. They are not. The U.S. Treasury holds senior preferred shares, but the non-Treasury preferreds are not guaranteed by the federal government. Another misconception is that if the GSEs are recapitalized, the preferreds will automatically be made whole. In reality, the FHFA and Treasury have broad discretion; the preferreds could be converted, exchanged, or written down as part of any reform.
Another frequent error is assuming that because dividends are non-cumulative, they are like common stock dividends. They are not—preferreds have a higher claim and are less volatile, but they still carry equity risk.
How They Compare to Other Investments
Compared to bank preferred stocks, GSE preferreds are riskier because of the conservatorship and the non-cumulative feature. Bank preferreds are also non-cumulative, but banks are regulated and can be resolved by the FDIC, which has a clear process. GSEs are in a unique legal limbo.
Compared to GSE common shares, preferreds are safer: they have a higher claim and pay a fixed dividend (if resumed). However, common shares have more upside if the GSEs are recapitalized and the common stock appreciates. Preferreds are capped at par (unless a conversion is offered), so the upside is limited.
Compared to corporate bonds, preferreds are riskier and have no maturity, but they offer higher yields. They are also less liquid.
Costs and Practical Considerations
These preferreds trade over-the-counter, so you may incur wider spreads and may not be able to use limit orders easily. Some brokers charge extra fees for OTC stocks. Also, dividends (if paid) are taxed as qualified dividends, but since they are currently suspended, there is no income to tax. The main cost is opportunity cost: your capital is tied up in a security with no income and uncertain appreciation.
Safety and Due Diligence
There is no safety net. Before buying, read the prospectus for the specific series. Check the dividend history, the call features, and the liquidation preference. Understand that the GSEs’ future is a political decision, not a financial one. If you cannot afford to lose the entire investment, do not buy these shares. They are speculative securities, not income investments.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac preferred shares guaranteed by the government?
No. The U.S. government does not guarantee these preferred shares. The Treasury holds senior preferred shares, but the non-Treasury preferreds are not backed by the full faith and credit of the United States.
Will the dividends ever be paid again?
There is no guarantee. Dividends have been suspended since 2008. If the GSEs exit conservatorship and are recapitalized, the FHFA and Treasury could decide to resume dividends, but they could also cancel or convert the preferreds.
What happens if the GSEs are recapitalized?
It depends on the plan. The preferreds could be redeemed at par, exchanged for common stock, or written down. No one knows for sure. In any case, the preferreds’ value would likely change dramatically.
Can I lose more than I invest?
No. Since these are stocks, your loss is limited to the amount you invest. You cannot owe money beyond that.
Are these preferreds cumulative?
No. They are non-cumulative, meaning missed dividends are not owed to you. If a dividend is skipped, it is gone forever.
Where can I buy them?
They trade over-the-counter under tickers like FNMAT, FNMAH, FMCKJ, etc. You can buy them through most brokerage accounts, but be aware of wider spreads and potential fees.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Unbox ASMR Codes: What They Are & How to Use5.00 min/km
- Repurposed Old Motorola Phone for Homelab?
- How to Evaluate AI Vendors for Data Security, Privacy & Compliance
- Best Ergonomic Mouse: Top Picks & Buying Guide
- Captions in Google Slides: How to Add & Format Them
- Use Mac Type in Japanese? Full Guide