The Redmi Note 5 Pro and the Poco F1 are two Xiaomi phones from the same era, but they serve very different buyers. The Note 5 Pro is a mid-range phone with a great camera and battery, while the Poco F1 is a flagship killer with a much faster processor. This article compares their specs, performance, cameras, and value to help you decide which one fits your needs.
Background: Why These Two Phones Are Often Compared
Xiaomi launched the Redmi Note 5 Pro in early 2018 as a mid-range device, and the Poco F1 later that year as a performance-focused sub-brand. Both phones quickly became popular in markets like India and Southeast Asia because they offered excellent value. The Note 5 Pro was praised for its dual cameras and long battery life, while the Poco F1 gained a cult following for bringing a flagship Snapdragon 845 chip to a budget price. Because they were released close together and shared Xiaomi’s design language, many buyers wondered if the extra cost of the Poco F1 was worth it.
Specs at a Glance
- Redmi Note 5 Pro: Snapdragon 636, 4/6 GB RAM, 64 GB storage, 5.99-inch IPS LCD, 4000 mAh battery, dual 12 MP + 5 MP rear cameras, 20 MP front camera.
- Poco F1: Snapdragon 845, 6/8 GB RAM, 64/128/256 GB storage, 6.18-inch IPS LCD, 4000 mAh battery, dual 12 MP + 5 MP rear cameras, 20 MP front camera.
Both phones have a microSD slot, a headphone jack, and run MIUI (Xiaomi’s custom Android skin). The Poco F1 also has a liquid cooling system, which helps keep the chip cool during gaming.
Performance: The Biggest Difference
The Snapdragon 845 in the Poco F1 is a flagship chip from 2018, while the Snapdragon 636 in the Note 5 Pro is a mid-range chip. In real-world use, the Poco F1 feels noticeably faster when opening apps, multitasking, and especially when playing graphically demanding games like PUBG Mobile or Asphalt 9. The Note 5 Pro handles everyday tasks like social media and web browsing fine, but it will stutter on heavy games or when many apps are open. If you are a gamer or want a phone that will stay smooth for a few years, the Poco F1 is the clear winner.
Camera and Battery: Where the Note 5 Pro Holds Its Own
Both phones have the same 12 MP + 5 MP dual rear camera setup, but the Note 5 Pro’s camera is often considered slightly better in daylight because of its Sony IMX486 sensor. The Poco F1 uses a similar sensor but has a different tuning. In practice, both take good photos for their price, but the Poco F1’s camera can struggle with dynamic range in bright scenes. The front cameras are identical (20 MP), so selfies look similar. Battery life is also comparable—both have 4000 mAh batteries and can easily last a full day, but the Note 5 Pro’s less power-hungry chip may give it a slight edge in standby time.
Build Quality and Features
The Redmi Note 5 Pro has a metal unibody design, while the Poco F1 uses a plastic back (with a kevlar or carbon-fiber option on some variants). The Poco F1 is slightly heavier and thicker, but it feels sturdy. Both phones have a rear fingerprint sensor and face unlock, but the Poco F1’s face unlock is faster because it uses the more powerful processor. The Poco F1 also supports Quick Charge 3.0, so it charges faster than the Note 5 Pro, which only supports standard 5V/2A charging.
Software and Updates
Both phones launched with MIUI 9 based on Android 8.1. Xiaomi later updated both to MIUI 10 and 11, but the Poco F1 received Android 10, while the Note 5 Pro was left on Android 9. This means the Poco F1 got one more major Android update. If you care about software longevity, the Poco F1 is a safer bet.
Price and Value in 2024
As of 2024, both phones are no longer sold new, but you can find them on the used market. The Poco F1 typically costs more than the Note 5 Pro because of its faster chip and better software support. However, if you are on a tight budget and only need a phone for basic tasks, the Note 5 Pro is still a decent choice. If you can afford the extra money, the Poco F1 offers much better performance and will feel more modern.
How to Choose Between Them
- If you play games or use demanding apps, choose the Poco F1.
- If you prefer a metal body and slightly better camera tuning, choose the Note 5 Pro.
- If you want the latest Android version, choose the Poco F1.
- If you are on a very tight budget, the Note 5 Pro is cheaper.
Common Problems and Misconceptions
A common misconception is that the Poco F1 has a worse camera than the Note 5 Pro. In reality, both are very similar, and the difference is minor. Another issue is that the Poco F1’s plastic back can scratch easily, so a case is recommended. Also, some users report that the Note 5 Pro’s touch screen has ghost-touch issues after a few years, but this is not universal.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Poco F1 still good in 2024?
Yes, for basic tasks and even some gaming, the Poco F1 is still usable. The Snapdragon 845 can handle most apps, but you will not get the latest Android updates, and the battery may have degraded over time.
Which phone has a better camera?
They are nearly identical. The Note 5 Pro has a slight edge in daylight, but the Poco F1 performs better in low light due to its newer image processing.
Can I use the Poco F1 for gaming?
Yes, the Poco F1 is excellent for gaming, even by today’s standards. It can run most games at medium to high settings.
Does the Redmi Note 5 Pro support fast charging?
No, the Note 5 Pro only supports standard 5V/2A charging. The Poco F1 supports Quick Charge 3.0, which is faster.
Which phone has better battery life?
Both have 4000 mAh batteries, but the Note 5 Pro’s less powerful chip may give it a slight advantage in standby time. In heavy use, the Poco F1 drains faster because of the more power-hungry processor.
Are these phones still worth buying in 2024?
Only if you are on a very tight budget and can find a good-condition used unit. Otherwise, newer budget phones offer better cameras, displays, and battery life.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Car Trends Making Cars Worse: 7 Downsides
- Nostalgic Classic Games Revamped on G2A?
- Nvidia RTX 4000 Super GPUs: Full Specs & Buying Guide
- Photoshop vs Lightroom AI Features Compared
- DNF vs DNF5: Which Package Manager?
- Korean SUV Making BMW and Audi Owners Question Their Choices?