This article explains the main reasons why writers and publishers choose not to use Medium for their content. You’ll learn about its paywall, lack of customization, limited SEO control, and other concrete drawbacks, so you can decide if it’s the right platform for your writing.
Background: What Medium Is and Why It Grew
Medium launched in 2012 as a publishing platform focused on long-form writing and community engagement. It gained popularity because it offered a clean reading experience, a built-in audience, and a simple editor. Writers could publish without worrying about hosting, design, or distribution – Medium handled all that. At its peak, it attracted millions of monthly readers, and its Partner Program (launched in 2017) promised to pay writers based on reading time from paying members. That promise drew thousands of writers, but many later found the platform’s limitations outweighed its benefits.
Paywall and Limited Audience Reach
The most cited reason to avoid Medium is its metered paywall. Non-subscribers can only read a few free stories per month before hitting a login wall. This directly reduces your potential audience – many casual readers won’t sign up just to read your article. Additionally, only paying members’ reading time counts toward your earnings, so if you have a large non-member audience, you get paid nothing for them. For example, a post that gets 10,000 views but only 100 member reads might earn less than $1, while a post with 500 member reads could earn $20. The paywall also hurts your ability to build a direct relationship with readers – they can’t easily subscribe to you without going through Medium’s system.
No Customization or Branding
Medium gives you almost no control over your page’s look and feel. You can choose a profile photo, a header image, and a short bio, but you cannot change fonts, colors, layout, or add custom CSS. Your articles appear with Medium’s standard design, which means your personal or business brand is invisible. If you’re a company trying to establish a distinct voice, or a freelancer wanting to showcase your portfolio, Medium makes you look like everyone else. You also can’t add custom calls-to-action, email signup forms, or product embeds beyond what Medium’s basic tools allow. This lack of branding is a dealbreaker for many professionals.
Limited SEO Control and Domain Authority
Medium does have decent domain authority, so your articles can rank on Google. However, you have very little control over technical SEO. You cannot edit meta titles and descriptions directly (Medium generates them from your title and first paragraph), you cannot add custom schema markup, and you cannot control URL structure – your post URL will always include medium.com/p/xxxx. This makes it hard to target specific keywords or optimize for featured snippets. Moreover, Medium has a history of changing its algorithms and even hiding some posts from Google results (as it did in 2017 when it blocked its paywall content from search engines). If you want long-term organic traffic, owning your own domain is far more reliable.
Algorithm Dependency and Content Discoverability
Medium’s homepage and topic pages are driven by an algorithm that prioritizes trending stories, publications, and topics. New or niche writers often get little to no exposure unless their story gets picked up by a large publication or goes viral through external shares. Unlike a blog where your content is always in your archive, Medium’s feed is ephemeral – your post gets a few days of attention, then disappears into the noise. This means you’re constantly chasing the algorithm, writing what’s popular rather than what’s valuable. Many writers report that their Medium traffic drops to near zero after the first week, making it a poor long-term content strategy.
No Ownership of Your Audience or Content
When you publish on Medium, you don’t own your audience – Medium does. You can’t export your follower list, and you have no way to contact readers directly outside of Medium’s messaging system (which is limited). If Medium changes its terms, shuts down, or you get banned, you lose all your followers and your content’s distribution. While you retain copyright to your writing, Medium’s terms give them a broad license to use your content, and if you delete your account, your posts are removed but may remain cached elsewhere. This lack of ownership is a fundamental reason many serious writers move to self-hosted blogs or other platforms where they control everything.
Monetization Limitations and Low Earnings
The Partner Program is the main monetization method, but earnings are notoriously low. Most writers earn less than $100 per month, and many earn nothing at all. Medium takes a 50% cut of subscription revenue, and the remaining pool is distributed based on reading time – but the exact formula is opaque. You also can’t run your own ads, sell products, or use affiliate links in a way that’s effective, because Medium’s terms restrict self-promotion and direct sales. If you’re hoping to make a living from your writing, Medium’s monetization is a dead end compared to selling your own courses, books, or services.
Content Theft and Scraping Issues
Because Medium is a public platform, your content can be easily scraped and republished elsewhere without your permission. While Medium has a DMCA process, it’s reactive – you have to find the theft and file a complaint. Many writers have found their Medium articles copied word-for-word on other blogs, often with no attribution. This is especially problematic if you’re trying to maintain exclusive rights for a book or a client. On your own site, you have more technical measures (like disabling right-click or using plagiarism detection services) and legal recourse, but on Medium you’re at the mercy of the platform’s enforcement.
How to Choose: When to Use Medium vs. Alternatives
Medium can still be useful as a secondary distribution channel. Use it if:
- You want to reach Medium’s built-in audience without building a site from scratch.
- You’re experimenting with topics and want quick feedback.
- You’re already established elsewhere and want to republish content (with canonical tags to avoid SEO duplication).
Avoid Medium if you need full control, want to build a direct relationship with readers, or plan to monetize through your own products. In those cases, a self-hosted WordPress site, Substack, or a static site generator like Hugo gives you ownership and flexibility. You can always cross-post to Medium after publishing on your own site to get extra exposure without losing your primary home.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I make a full-time income on Medium?
Very few writers do. The top earners make thousands per month, but they are outliers with large followings and viral posts. The median earnings are much lower – often under $50 per month. Treat Medium as a bonus, not a primary income source.
Is Medium still good for SEO in 2024?
Medium has high domain authority, so your posts can rank, but you have limited control over meta tags and URL structure. If you’re serious about SEO, a self-hosted site with WordPress or a static site is better because you can optimize everything.
Does Medium own my content?
No, you retain copyright. However, Medium’s terms give them a broad license to use, distribute, and promote your content. You can delete your posts, but they may be cached or republished elsewhere.
Can I use Medium for free?
Yes, publishing is free. You only need a Medium account. The Partner Program requires a Stripe account and a minimum payout of $10, but joining is free.
Should I cross-post from my blog to Medium?
Yes, if you use the canonical tag feature to point to your original post. This avoids duplicate content penalties and lets you reach Medium’s audience without sacrificing your SEO. Just be aware that Medium’s paywall may still hide your post from non-members.
What are the best Medium alternatives?
Substack (for newsletters), WordPress.com (free), Ghost (paid, self-hosted), and your own static site. Each has different trade-offs in cost, control, and audience. Choose based on your goals: ownership, monetization, or ease of use.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Capture Cards: What They Do & How to Use Them
- Affordable Family Sedan: Quietly Reliable?
- Binge-Worthy Paramount Shows to Finish in One Sitting
- Affordable Pickup Trucks: Top Picks & Costs28,554 USD
- Halloween Desk Accessories: Spooky Picks
- Coupe High Octane Fun Sedan? Truth vs Hype